ingridscience

Evolution by natural selection

Summary
A running game shows the survival of a population depends on what it eats and what eats it. A camouflage challenge demonstrates how camouflage is a beneficial adaptation in both prey and predators. A relay race game shows how different bird beaks are adapted for carrying different foods. A lego-building activity shows how mutations result in a slow change in how an animal looks.
Materials

Materials in the activities

Procedure

Evolution is the gradual change in how living things look and behave as the generations cycle.
If a living thing has a feature, or "adaptation" that helps it survive, it might live long enough to have babies, and the babies will inherit this adaptation.

Adaptive changes happen through changes in DNA.
(DNA is in every cell. It is translated into proteins, which build the body, or regulate body processes.)
Tiny random changes in DNA (called mutations) sometimes change how a living thing looks or behaves.
If a mutation results in an adaptation that is beneficial to the living thing, the living thing will live longer and have more babies. Those babies will inherit those same DNA mutations.

To model how random DNA changes affect how an animal looks.
Do the lego evolution activity.

The camouflage activity (inside or outdoors) looks at one kind of adaptation (camouflage) which helps animals survive, whether they are a predator or prey animal.
Look at photos of ptarmigan birds in summer and winter - they grow feathers with different colours in different seasons, for best camouflage.

Natural selection game (outdoors or in large gym space) shows how populations shift as animals eat each other. (Suitable for all grades except Ks.)

Show how adaptations allow animals to use different food sources: bird beaks eating different food types. Fun as a relay race outdoors/in a gym; also indoors as a non-running game.

Notes

Bird beaks great for Ks hand-eye coordination.
Ks had fun with the camouflage activity though they tended to choose an environment that matched the clay, instead of making clay colours to match the environment (making it too easy to find the clay).

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Leaf growth patterns

Summary
Look at leaves growing from stems, and define the growth pattern as opposite, alternate or whorled.
Materials
  • streets or outdoor space with several trees and/or bushes
  • optional: App or book for identifying the plants
  • optional: clipboards and paper for students, paper or portable white board for teacher
Procedure

Take students outdoors where there are several bushes and trees.
Show students how to identify the pattern of leaves on the branches of trees or bushes - look a little way down the stem where the leaves are more spaced out. In the winter, when deciduous leaves have dropped, look at the pattern of the leaf buds. Draw on paper/portable white board to make the pattern clear.

Alternate: one leaf emerges from one side of the stem, the next leaf along from the other side.
Opposite: two leaves emerge from the same place on the stem, but on different sides.
Whorled: several leaves emerge from the same place on the stem.

Identify the trees as they are studied.
I found this free Vancouver Street Trees iphone App which identifies trees on Vancouver streets by location.

Students can use a map to mark where they found each kind of pattern.
Or they can make a Venn diagram of the plants they find and the growth pattern(s) they exhibit.
Note that different students may see different patterns in the same tree. Sometimes the patterns are not clear, especially if the leaves are close together at the tip of the stem.

Extension: look at the patterns of the veins in leaves (opposite or alternate) and compare to the leaf growth pattern from the stem in the same plant.

Discussion:
Although leaves have different patterns in how they grow, all the patterns ensure that the leaves are well spaced out around the stem. This allows each leaf to catch as much light as possible for the plant.
Through evolution, leaves that spread their leaves out were at an advantage over other plants, and this adaptation persisted.

The actual mechanism for leaf growth patterns (called phyllotaxis) involves a molecule called auxin, and is a current area of research.
Auxin is constantly flowing up the stem towards the growing tip. Where there is a lot of auxin, a new leaf grows. Auxin is drawn towards where a new leaf is growing, and is pulled away from the surrounding areas, depleting them of auxin. This means, as more auxin moves up the stem, it collects in areas further away from the last leaf. Once enough auxin builds up a new leaf grows, on the other side of the stem from the last leaf.
See this webpage for a visual: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Model-for-the-role-of-polar-auxin-t…

The growth of all living things is a result of their molecules flowing, interacting and changing, setting up patterns that we see in the structure of plants and animals e.g. patterns of ribs or body segments.

Grades taught
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6

Camouflage challenge

Summary
Hide modelling clay of different colours and learn about different kinds of camouflage. Can be run outdoors, or indoors in a visually busy space.
Materials
  • either outdoors: area of grass, rocky ground, tree roots or other outdoor area with a somewhat complex texture
  • or indoors: classroom or common area which includes visually busy areas e.g. art supplies, board signage
  • square made from four pipe cleaners
  • modelling clay of different colours (including brown and black for outdoor activity)
Procedure

Please note that in a class of students it is likely that one of them is at least partially colourblind (1 in 12 males are colourblind). As this is an activity distinguishing colours, these students will not be able to tell some colours apart and perceive some colours differently, although the activity will be no less interesting for them. The common red/green colour blindness means reds and greens (or colours containing reds and greens such as browns) look similar. More information at colourblindawareness.org and colorblindguide.com/post/the-advantage-of-being-colorblind.

This is an engaging activity. Student get involved in creating works of art that look like the surroundings.

Students work in pairs, or maximum groups of three. Each group has a pipe cleaner square and a tub of small pieces of modelling clay in a variety of colours.
Each group decides where to place their pipe cleaner square.

While one (or two) student(s) looks away, the other student makes a small ball of modelling clay of one colour, and places it in the square. The clay cannot have anything placed on top of it - it must be in plain sight.
The second student then looks and tries to find the clay.
Then the students switch tasks.
Black and brown modelling clay is often the hardest to find outdoors, matching the dirt between grass blades.
This kind of camouflage is an example of "colour matching". Animals are often colour matched to their environment to make them harder to find.

Another kind of camouflage is "disruptive colouration" where a living thing is more than one colour, maybe with spots or stripes. The different colours break up the outline of the living thing and make it harder to see.
Another level of camouflage is to have an "irregular outline", so the shape of the object is not what is expected. Some fish have decorated heads, or insects look like a leaf.
Students can try adding these layers of camouflage to their colour matching, by adding different colours of clay and changing the shape of their clay before hiding it. The final object should be about the same size of the first ball (as a tiny speck of clay will be an unfair challenge).

Examples of outdoor variations that students came up with: making a long piece of clay to look like a stick on the ground, or a piece of gray and black clay shaped to look like other little rocks on the ground, matching the colour of peeling paint on a fence, or even matching the colour of bird poop on a rock! (see this website for animals camouflaging to look like bird poop: https://www.sciencefocus.com/nature/heres-looking-at-poo-the-weird-and-…)
Examples of indoor variations include hiding colours in a collection of coloured art supplies, or adding extra coloured patches to coloured tags. Posters or other flat materials are easier for finding hidden clay on, as the clay is the only raised part and reflects the light differently.

Students can spend quite a while making works of art that can be a challenge to find by most in the class. Student groups and adults will enjoy visiting particularly challenging hides.

Please note the likelihood of a colourblind student in the class. Colourblindness can also be an advantage:
https://lifeonsphere.com/color-blind-people-can-spot-and-see-through-ca…
https://www.science.org/content/article/eye-camouflage#:~:text=Being%20….

Animals using different methods of camouflage:
https://www.bbcearth.com/news/8-creatures-that-are-masters-of-disguise

Webpages with lists of camouflage types:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_camouflage_methods
https://www.eecis.udel.edu/~vijay/BLAST/Lesson_5.html

Notes

Ks have fun with this activity, though tend to choose their clay colour first, then find a place to hide it, which often makes it too easy to find. (Maybe limit their clay colours to those in the environment?)

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Rain gauge

Summary
Build a simple rain gauge from a recycled bottle and measure rainfall.
Materials
  • 2L plastic drink bottle
  • scissors/sharp blade
  • ruler, or ruler scale duplicated onto a plastic sheet
  • clear tape
  • clean rocks
  • 2 mini binder clips
  • optional: smaller tube that fits over the mouth of the drink bottle, electrical tape and fine sharpie
Procedure

NOTE: this activity has not been tested with a class of students. Please contact me with suggestions if you try it with students.

Cut the top off the 2L bottle, where the neck widens to the main body.
Tape a ruler on the inside of the bottle, the numbers facing outwards, with zero at the base of where the sides are parallel.
Add clean rocks (to weigh it down) then place in a shady location (to minimize water evaporation) with open sky above (no nearby wall or overhanging branches). Insert the top of the bottle upside down, and clip together.
Make sure the rain gauge is sitting level, then fill with water until the water line is at the zero on the ruler.

Hourly (if there is a lot of rain) or daily/weekly, read off how much rain has fallen. After each reading, either take apart and reset to the water line at zero on the ruler, or record the difference in mm of rain from the last reading.
Tabulate and graph the readings.

Optional set up to get more accurate readings:
Attach a narrow tube to the mouth of the bottle, so that the depth of water will change more dramatically for smaller readings.
Before adding the tube to the system, calculate the scale to add to the tube: calculate the relative surface area of the circles at the top of the 2L drink bottle and the small tube. This will be the relative difference between the spacing on the two scales (e.g. if the 2L bottle circle is 4 times larger, the scale on the small tube will be 4 times more spaced out). Calculate and write a new scale on electrical tape and tape to the side of the narrow tube, before inserting on the mouth of the bottle. Then clip the rain gauge together, as before.

To give a sense of what readings to expect, light rain is only 1mm an hour or less. To read 5mm in an hour it needs to be steady solid rain.

Note that despite the placement of the rain gauge, there will be some evaporation, so readings will not be as accurate as a professional rain gauge. A professional rain gauge style is "tipping bucket" - the rain fills up a little bucket, which is dumped and counted as it becomes full, hence there is way less sitting water to evaporate.

Density, buoyancy and pressure

Summary
Understand density in terms of molecules, and how varying densities determine how buoyant things are and what pressure is.
Materials
  • materials in each of the activities
  • a kitchen scale and graduated cylinder/beaker to measure density
Procedure

Review density:
Density is how heavy something is compared to its size. Density depends on how close the molecules are together and what kinds of molecules make up an object.
In solids the molecules are closer together, so solids are generally more dense than liquids, which are generally more dense than gases i.e. a desk is heavier than the air, a rock is more dense than water. Explained in another way, the rock sinks in water because the mass of the rock is greater than the same volume of water that it replaces. Its weight (the force of gravity pulling on its mass) is greater than the upwards force from the water (force of buoyancy).
Sometimes a solid can float on water e.g. a piece of wood. This is because wood has tubes running through it (filled with sap when the tree is alive) which fill with air when wood is dried out. The overall density of a piece of wood is the combined densities of the wood and the air it contains. If this is less than the density of water, the wood floats. (Some kinds of very dense wood, even when dried out, sink.)

Students try the dancing raisins activity at their desk, in smaller tubes, and think about why they move up and down. Then do a larger demonstration in a cylinder, while discussing why they dance.

Sinking floating challenge 2. Once students have added just the right amount of nails/paperclips/modelling clay to their styrofoam piece to make it float half way down in the water, calculate its density, and compare to the density of water (1g/ml). The answers should be similar.

Discuss pressure:
When a gas (or liquid) is compressed to bring its molecules closer together, it exerts a pressure on the walls of its container.
Do an activity that exploits pressure:
Stomp rocket.
(Pressure in a bottle and popcorn also good pressure experiments to add here.)

Grades taught
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Motor free play

Summary
Build motors into electric circuits and use cardboard to make fans, buzz saws and spin art.
Materials
  • home made wires, wires cut from holiday lights, or purchased electrical wires
  • batteries, I use AA size
  • small motors e.g. from Canada Robotix (hobby DC motors and/or hobby gear motors (which turn more slowly)
  • masking tape
  • card stock and scissors
  • marker pens
  • pipe cleaners and other found craft materials
Procedure

Students build a motor into a simple electric circuit: a battery and motor, connected into a loop with wires, using masking tape to attach the wires to each component. When the loop of the circuit is closed, the shaft on the motor will turn, but often so fast that it might be hard to see - put your finger on it to feel it turn.

Once students have their motor working, show them the card stock and other materials, which they can tape to the shaft of the motor.
Ideas:
Fan - a small circle of card with angled blades blows air.
Saw - a small circle of card with a serrated edge can cut through a piece of tin foil or thin paper.
Colour wheel - add colours to a circle of card. When it spins the colours blur together.

Students can also add holiday lights into the circuit - see the helicopter in the last photo.

Grades taught
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Physical changes introduction

Summary
Manipulate materials and decide if the physical change is reversible or not. Then make ooblek.
Procedure

Introduction to physical change stations, followed by discussion of which physical changes are reversible.
Make ooblek - a physical change. It is reversible and can be seen when water evaporates from a small drop of ooblek leaving the powdery cornstarch behind.
Study a physical change, water changing state, in more detail, by measuring the temperature of water in different states.

Grades taught
Gr 2

Anemometer

Summary
Build a simple cup anemometer to show wind speed.
Materials
  • pieces of styrofoam, about 2cm x 2cm x 4cm (blue insulation foam works well)
  • small pen cap or tube, that can be pushed into the end of the styrofoamfoam piece
  • short skewers
  • cardboard egg cartons
  • hot glue gun
Procedure

Prepare the foam ahead of class:
Make a small hole with scissors in the end of a piece of foam and push the tube/pen cap into it. A skewer inserted into the tube allows the foam to spin freely on the skewer.
Make small holes in an egg carton cups and push a skewer through them. Hot glue the skewer in place. (Note: the skewers are a little long in the photo - push them further through before glueing.)

Students assemble their anemometer by pushing the cup skewers into the foam in a circle. Three or four cups work, but younger students may have an easier time spacing out four (one on each side of the foam piece). Ideally the cups are all facing the same direction - help younger students to assemble, and allow older students to experiment with cup placement.
Insert a skewer (with no cup attached) into the hole that the pen cap/tube makes in the foam.

Blow into the cups to turn.

Try experimenting with different numbers of cups, and different strength of breath.

A weather station anemometer has metal cups which are weather-proof. The speed of the spinning cups is recorded as wind speed.

Notes

Wind speed with a ping pong ball on a string: https://www.howtosmile.org/resource/measuring-wind-speed

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1

Mountain landforms and their erosion

Summary
Build models of mountains from a simple contour map, read contour lines on a large map, then use sand and water to show how erosion shapes landforms.
Procedure

Sit around a paper contour map of local mountains/hills e.g. Vancouver North Shore.
Map with heights also coloured: The colours help us see the heights, but we don't need it with the lines, or contours. The shape of the lines show the shape of the land.

You'll build a model of a mountain from a contour map.
Demonstrate then run Landform models.

As students make their model they bring it, and their corresponding contour map to the tarp, and lay them down to build two identical landscapes - one of the landform models and one of the corresponding contour maps.
As a class, look at the landscape and the contour maps. Refer back and forth while discussing and highlighting features of a contour map
e.g. When lines are close together, a slop is steep
e.g. When lines are far apart, a slope rises gradually
e.g. A valley forms between slopes, and the contour lines go up and back across the valley
e.g. a bay, a peninsular, a cliff
Refer back to the local paper map, and find these landform features.

Explain that Erosion makes these shapes in the land.
Water, ice and wind wear away parts of the land to make valleys and other landform shapes.

Watch erosion in action with the sand and water erosion activity, at table groups of four, or as a demonstration.
Note that the Erosion model is sped up a lot - valleys form over thousands or millions of year (depending on the rock type).

Maps needs to constantly change as the landscape changes.

Grades taught
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4

Landform models

Summary
Use a simple contour maps to assemble 3D models of mountains with valleys. Combine class mountains into a landscape that can be compared to a contour map.
Materials
  • simple contour map of a mountain or hill on a half-sheet of paper, two identical copies
  • ball of playdough, about two cups
  • plastic tubes to use as rolling pins (they don't stick to the play dough as much as wood)
  • plastic knife or butter knife
  • table mat to protect the table from play dough and knives
  • scissors
  • tarp to lay landscapes on
  • optional: toothpick, if the contour map is more complex e.g. two peaks
Procedure

Ahead of the lesson: print simple contour maps on half sheets of paper (see attached file). Each one is a little different e.g. some have steeper slopes; for capable students include river valleys (E1 and E2 on attached file). Make a duplicate copy of each contour map.

With students, look at a topographic map that shows the height of land in different colours, either on a large paper map, or projected
e.g. North Shore mountains of Vancouver
e.g. this map of Hawaii: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hawaii_Island_topographic_map-f…
On Hawaii map: ask students how many mountains there are on the map (two or four).
On any map with colours: point out the colour changes as the height changes.
On any map: Then point out the lines - these are called contours and show where the land gets higher. The colours are not needed with these 'contour lines'.
Then optionally look at a map that shows only the contours, lacking colour changes with height e.g. this map of North Vancouver and nearby Islands: http://www.canmaps.com/topomaps/nts50/toporama/images/092g06.gif
Show them the contours and tell students that they show how high the land is. Their spacing tells us how steep or gentle a slope is, and where there are river valleys and plateaus.

Tell students they will make their own model of a mountain from a simple contour map.
Demonstrate the activity, before students run it themselves (pairs work well):
Cut out a contour map around its outer edge, while the other student rolls out about half of the play dough to about 1cm thick, or until it is large enough to fit the contour map on it.
Lay the cut piece (showing the shape of the lowest level of the contour map) on the play dough and use the knife to cut out the shape. Lay the shape to one side of the mat.
Now, cut out around the next smallest contour line, and roll out a new piece of play dough (students can switch roles). Lay the (now smaller) contour map on the new rolled-out play dough and cut out the (new) shape. Lay the new play dough shape over the first one, using the duplicate contour map, to show where to lay the second layer over the first layer.
Repeat with the following contour lines, cutting out their shapes in play dough, and using the un-cut contour map to show how to align the layers on the growing mountain.

(For older students, more complex mountains with two peaks can be made.) If there is any doubt how to align one layer on the next, use a toothpick to help:
Before picking up the first paper contour cut-out, stick a toothpick through the paper and into the play dough in several places. When subsequent layers are made, push the toothpick through the same holes in the paper into the rolled-out play dough before removing the paper. The toothpick holes in the play dough can be aligned to place each layer in its proper position.

Once their mountains is made, students can cut their duplicate contour map along the outer contour line only, then bring their mountain and duplicate contour map to the tarp, where they are placed for display on separate halves of the tarp. As new mountains are added, place them next to the previous ones, and place the corresponding contour maps in equivalent positions in their own area. The growing landscape of model mountains will be reflected in the growing contour map assembly next to it.
(As students understand the relationship between the growing mountain landscape and the adjacent contour map, they can help direct where to place the contour maps correctly.)

As a class, look at the landscape and the contour maps. Refer back and forth while discussing and highlighting these features of a contour map:
The mountains look like islands in the ocean (the tarp is the ocean water).
Where are the steep slopes and the gentle slopes on the play dough mountains? Look at the contour maps to see what the lines do [lines are close together on steep slopes and far apart on gentle slopes].
Optional (and with warning to students that their creations will be modified): smooth out the sides of each mountain, so they look more like real mountains, commenting that the lines show the heights, but real mountains don't go up in steps.
Ask students to find valleys on the play dough mountains, which rivers might run down. Then show the same valleys on their contour maps - the contour lines have a distinctive shape, curving up and back, in a valley. Show them river valleys on a real map/the projected map (which likely also has a blue river line).
Refer back and forth between the landscapes while discussing and highlighting landforms that the students know about (e.g. mountains, hills, plateaus, valleys, deltas).

As a class, look back at a real contour map (preferably in an area that students are familiar with e.g. the same Cypress mountain map with the Sea-to Sky highway) and try to read the mountains: the steep slopes, the gentle slopes, the narrow river valleys (formed by water) and wide river valleys (formed by glaciers).

Optional and advanced: Students modify their mountains, then make a new contour map of their new mountain (not tested with a class).

Grades taught
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4