Ultimate Building Book
Steven Caney's Ultimate Building Book. 2006. Running Press Kids.
Steven Caney's Ultimate Building Book. 2006. Running Press Kids.
Creepy Crawlies and the Scientific Method by Sally Kneidel. 1993. Fulcrum Resources.
Mirrors by Bernie Zubrowski. A Boston Children's Museum Activity Book. 1992. Morrow.
On Food and Cooking by Harold McGee. 2004. Scribner
Kitchen Science by Chris Maynard. 2001. DK
101 Great Science Experiments by Neil Ardley. 2006. DK
ISBN-13: 978-0-75662-220-6.2006.DK
For each pair or small group of students:
Stands alone as a 1.5hr lesson, with a good amount of time for free exploration, ending with looking at photos of local bridges and understanding the Forces in them.
Tell students they will be making different kinds of bridge structures and testing their strength. Bridge supports are tubs of sand or stacks of books. All the bridges are made with the same amount of material - two sheets of paper (quarter of a letter-sized sheet), so that the different shapes can be compared for strength.
For Ks, show them how to make only beam and girder. For older primaries or intermediates, show them how to make beam, arch, girder and truss.
A beam bridge is simply two sheets of paper on top of each other, spanning the bridge supports.
An arch bridge is made by curving one sheet of paper between the two bridge supports, then laying the second sheet of paper over the arch so that it rests on the top of the arch as well as the bridge supports.
A girder bridge (a strengthened beam bridge) is made by folding up the sides of one or both sheets of paper - make sure the students fold the long sides and the folds are across the gap between the supports.
A truss bridge (a strengthened beam bridge) is made by creasing one sheet of paper into an accordion length wise, then laying the second sheet of paper over the accordion - make sure the folds are across the gap.
For each bridge type, test its strength by adding a small pot to the centre of the bridge, then adding counters until the bridge collapses.
If a pot starts to get filled, stack on a second cup, so that the force is still in the same spot of the bridge deck (and not spread out).
Tell students after testing these bridges, they can also make up their own bridge shapes, but to compare their strength to the others, they must also only be made from two sheets of paper.
Students come together to record their results on a class graph. The class results will show the data pattern clearly, even if individual results are not so striking.
It is expected that the beam bridge will be the weakest and the girder or truss bridge the strongest (though depending on the number of creases in the truss this can make a huge difference to its strength). There is a fair amount of variability in the data (though beam and arch bridge data seems to be quite clean), but the highest point can be looked at, or the rough average of the points. the variability in truss bridge strength may be because students make differently-sized folds in their paper.
Discuss the forces in each bridge:
When the load is added to the beam bridge there is force pushing down in one area of the flat surface of the paper, soon bending it. When the load is added to the arch bridge the force is spread out by the arch to the sides, so that less force is experienced in more places. Hence more load can be added before the paper bends.
The folds of the girder bridge direct force sideways and distributes it through the bridge. The truss bridge has triangles underneath, which are strong shapes that do not easily distort and spread the forces out so the bridge can take even more load (though these triangles are not strapped at the top, so are weaker than complete triangles).
(More details on bridge construction and forces at http://science.howstuffworks.com/engineering/civil/bridge.htm)
Look at bridge photos (local if possible):
Beam bridge: a log bridge, or plank over a river (see https://afriprov.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/aug-1-05.jpg)
Girder bridges: Oak Street, Knight street.
Truss bridges: Granville Street, Burrard Street, Second Narrows Ironworkers Memorial
Arch bridges: Second Narrows
Other bridge shapes not covered with this activity:
Suspension bridge: Lions gate
Cable-stayed bridge: Alex Fraser (longest in the world when built), Port Mann
Depending on how wide the river that the bridge crosses, the materials that the banks are made from, and whether piers can be built in the river, and the cost of the materials, different bridge styles are chosen for each location. For each location the engineers determined the best bridge type. In general, a simple beam bridge is not used for longer bridges.
Discuss the elements that are used to construct a real bridge:
Structural elements are long beams, made of steel or wood. They are rigid and transmit forces along them, to distribute the force of the load throughout the structure.
Fasteners attach the structural elements together: bolts, straps to crimp structural elements together. Welding, gluing and cement are also used.
Ideas to continue experimenting and graphing:
If you build a beam bridge from several stacked pieces of paper, how many pieces of paper makes it as strong as an arch bridge/truss bridge made from 2 pieces? How much more material does the beam bridge need than the other kinds of bridges to be as strong?
Students can design their own bridge structures.
More info on bridge websites:
http://www.historyofbridges.com
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/buildingbig/bridge/index.html
https://www.explainthatstuff.com/bridges.html
http://www.highestbridges.com
Using a styrofoam cup instead of little paper cups, which are light, will fit all the counters in one cup. Cups do not have to be stacked up (though this is fun!). Make sure the base of the styrofoam cup is not too wide, so that it is really sitting on the bridge structure and not over the supports.
Identifying flavour by taste alone:
Tell students what three flavours of jellybeans they will be tasting.
Ask students to close their eyes and pinch their nose shut.
Give them a jelly bean, and ask them to put it in their mouth and chew a couple of times, still with the nose pinched. (Do this for just a couple of seconds as it is hard to make the instinctive swallow with the nose pinched.) Can they identify the jelly bean taste? At this point students might find it hard, as they just taste sweet.
Then ask students to un-pinch their nose and see if they can identify the taste now. As smell molecules from the jellybean pass through their open nasal passage, smells are now detected, and the "taste" should be immediately identifiable.
Summarize: most of the "taste" of jellybeans is actually smell molecules. When they make jellybeans they add smells to a sugar paste. When we chew the smells are released. The colour of jellybeans also cues us into what flavour they are.
Identifying flavour by smell alone:
Tell students what three flavours of jellybeans they will be smelling.
Give a student a jellybean without them looking at the flavour.
Ask them to crush it, or break it in half, then smell it. Can they identify the flavour?
Then they can taste it.
They will likely be able to identify the flavour from smell alone, as the "taste" of jellybeans is determined by the smell molecules added to a sugar paste.
Note that texture also plays an important part in food experience, so foods with similar textures may need to be used for when students switch roles.
Variation done at NY after school programs: Students work in pairs. One student keeps their eyes closed. The other student offers a food at a time for smelling, then tasting. The blindfolded student tries to guess what the food is before looking. e.g. use raisins, carrots, apple, cheese, banana, orange, potato chips
Students dip their Q-tip in the food dye and water, then paint the blue onto their tongue.
Students can look at each others' tongues and use the mirror to look at their own.
They may need to use a flashlight to see properly.
They are looking for the pink bumps on the tongue, that do not stain blue. The blue dye will help contrast them with the surrounding tongue.
Some of the pink bumps (called papillae) contain taste buds, which detect tastes. Some papillae do not, but are used for detecting touch.
There are five established basic tastes, from separate taste buds detecting different molecules or ions:
Sweet detects sugar/protein when they bind.
Sour detects hydrogen ions, when they enter the taste bud.
Salt detects Na+, K+ or Li+ ions when they enter the taste bud.
Bitter from molecules binding a receptor.
Umami is glutamic acid binding a receptor.
Taste buds, which contain the taste receptor cells, are distributed throughout the tongue, on the papillae. All the tastes are found all over the tongue.
Note that the myth that divides the tongue into different areas with different kinds of taste buds is incorrect. (Explanation: the original scientific paper showed tiny differences in detection levels across the tongue, but this was misunderstood and reported in textbooks as a difference in sensitivity.)
Image of the papillae on the tongue, which contain the taste buds at https://basicmedicalkey.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/F500414f28-04-97… Taste buds are found on fungiform, foliate and circumvallate papillae, but not filiform papillae (which detect touch).
The tongue can detect other sensations, not classically described as taste: spiciness, temperature, coolness (minty), numbness, astringency, metallicness, calcium, fattniess, starchiness (Wikipedia: Taste)
Different students will have different densities of taste buds.
Super tasters have the greatest density of taste buds, normal tasters have fewer and non-tasters have the least.
(More than about 30 fungiform papillae they are considered a supertaster, if they have around 15 to 30 papillae they are an average taster, and if they have fewer than 15 papillae they are a non-taster. Of world population 25-30% are thought to be supertasters, 40-50% average tasters, and 25-30% non-tasters.)
http://usd-apps.usd.edu/coglab/TasteLab.html
To supertasters, foods may have much stronger flavors, which often leads to supertasters having very strong likes and dislikes for different foods. Supertasters often report that foods like broccoli, cabbage, spinach, grapefruit and coffee taste very bitter. The opposite of supertasters are non-tasters. Non-tasters have very few taste buds and, to them, most food may seem bland and unexciting.
Food dye stain does not come off for an hour or two (similar to blue candy), so let parents know of activity.
Optional: use paper ring reinforcers to isolate and count a group of taste buds, to determine density: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/super-tasting-science-find-o…