ingridscience

Seed germination and gravity

Summary
Bean seeds are planted at different angles, to test which way the roots and shoots grow. Done as a demonstration.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Materials
  • Jar for each set up
  • coffee filter
  • Paper towels
  • Water
  • 3 or 4 large bean seeds (e.g. broad bean) per jar
Procedure

What might affect the direction that roots grow?
(Students might suggest water, darkness....)

Put some beans in a jar at different angles to test which way the root and shoot grows each time:
Make a ring of coffee filters paper towels inside the jar, and stuff the centre with more paper towels.
Add water to the paper towels until they are wet and there is a small puddle at the bottom of the jar.
Push the bean seeds between the coffee filter ring and the glass jar wall, to hold them in place, each at a different angle, spread out around the jar.

One week later:
What can we conclude about something other than water and air (and darkness) that seed germination is sensitive to? Gravity.
Which way up should we plant a seed? (Doesn’t matter)

Results:
The roots always grow downwards, then the shoot upwards.
The seeds are uniformly wet and exposed to light, so they use gravity to determine which way to grow.

Notes

Apparently, this can be set up with a pin through the bean.
The lid can be rested on to keep water evaporation to a minimum, while allowing air to get into the jar.
This is a good activity to show the results of after other germination factors have been determined.

Grades taught
Gr 3

Seed germination requirements

Summary
Grow mung bean seeds in tubs under different conditions (oxygen, water, light, and maybe other variables suggested by students) to find out what they need to germinate.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Needs of Living Things (grade 1)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Materials
  • Mung bean seeds, 15-20 per tub. Optional: soak in water a couple of hours before the activity to speed up germination without changing the appearance of the seeds.
  • Tub for each condition at each table group (I use cream cheese/deli tubs - they are shallow and stable).
  • Paper towels.
  • Saran wrap
  • Tin foil
  • Water to wet towels.
  • Masking tape to label tubs
Procedure

Plants come from seeds. Why don’t these seeds turn into plants? They need certain conditions to germinate.
We’ll test what seeds need to grow into plants.

Work in table groups to set up 3 experiments:
1. seeds on wet paper towel (get water and air and light) - crunch up a paper towel in the bottom of the tub, wet it, then lay over a folded paper towel to make a damp, flat surface for the seeds. Layer some saran wrap over the top with small holes punched in it, to let in the light, but keep water from evaporating away as fast.
2. dry seeds in tub (get air and light, no water)
3. seeds under water (get water and light, no air) - put seeds in a tub filled with water.
4. seeds on wet paper towel wrapped in foil (get water and air, no light) - set up as 1 then wrap in foil to keep the light out. Open each day briefly to let plenty of oxygen in.
5+ Add other variables that students come up with that are dooable e.g. adding soil (the seeds have water and air, but no light if they are buried in the soil). e.g. keeping the seeds cold e.g. damaging the seeds (mimic damage by pests by puncturing or cutting the seeds)

Optional: make predictions about what will happen. Doesn’t matter whether you are right or wrong. It just gets you thinking about it.

Leave tubs in a warm spot for a week. Make sure the wet conditions stay wet - check at least once a day. The seeds under water will need to have their water changed, so that mould growth does not take over.

One week to 10 days later:
Did you have a look during the week at your seeds? What did you notice? Look at all your experiment dishes. What do you see?
The long white thing coming out of the seed is the root, and comes first. Then the shoot, which is green, and might have distinct leaves.
Record average root and shoot length for each of the tubs. Combine results into a class chart.

Expected results:
The seeds in the dark with water and oxygen grew the most in a week - they had long roots and many had shoots too.
The seeds with water in the light grew the next best. They had roots, but they had turned brown at the ends and very few had shoots.
The seeds with water but no oxygen grew the next best. They had split open and had sent out a root, but it stopped growing pretty quickly.
The seeds with no water did not grow at all.
Conclude as a class what seeds need to germinate (water, air, darkness).

Possible additional variables and results:
Seeds with soil grow well (they have darkness, wet, oxygen and also nutrients from the soil).
Seeds in the cold do not grow well (discuss: seed germination is triggered by the warmth of spring).
Seeds that are damaged sometimes germinate (discuss: probably depending on whether the embryo is been damaged or just the cotyledons).

Optional continuation of experiment:
Continue the experiment with the plants that are growing OK (should be the seeds in the darkness either on the wet paper towels or in soil), to find out what the plants need once they have germinated.
Results should show that plants need light when the leaves appear. With no light, the leaves are present but pale green.

Attached documents
Notes

Mung bean seeds need darkness to germinate well. But this is apparently not always the case. Other plants need light, or are not affected by light conditions for germination to happen.

With a grade 3 class, I suspected that some of the students took away that plants need darkness, missing the subtlety that they need darkness for germination, then light for growth once the leaves are formed.
If the plants are allowed to grow more once the leaves are formed, distinguish between germination, and subsequent plant growth after leaf formation.

If seeds are soaked beforehand, do not do for so long that they are already making roots. (Overnight soaking is too long). Giving the students dry seeds to start takes a little longer to get going, and gives slightly more variable results.

Grades taught
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4

Plant parts

Summary
Look at parts of a plant. Make soup from plant parts.
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Materials

See individual activities.

Procedure

Dissect a seed to find where a plant comes from

Which parts of the plant do we eat?
Idea: add images names of example fruits and veg to the projected plant drawing.

Gazpacho soup.

Look at Fruit and vegetable search in art. at any point in the lesson.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 3

The Reason for a Flower

Summary
Covers the huge variety of flowers, pollinators, pollen types, seed types and shows the cycle from one to the next.
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Type of resource
Book
Resource details

The Reason for a Flower, by Ruth Heller. Puffin Publishers. 1999

Notes

Text confusing. Not recommended for this.
But, a great image of flower to fruit inside front and back covers.

Plant parts that we eat

Summary
Sort real fruits and vegetables/garden produce into the parts of the plant they come from.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Materials
  • worksheet and pencil for each student (see image/attachment)
  • fruits and veggies representing each part of the plant we can eat, or plants in a garden to look at (e.g. carrot, parsnip, onion, celery, spinach, lettuce, broccoli, red pepper, tomato, apple)
  • image of flower into fruit (from The Reason for a Flower resource).
Procedure

We eat all parts of the plant, but have bred plants so that the part we eat is larger and tastier.
If necessary, review the names of the parts of the plant (see image and worksheet).

On the worksheet, first connect each label with the plant part.
For each plant on your table/in the garden, identify it, then add its name to the box labelled with the part of the plant that we eat. Some plants may go in two boxes.
Discuss with your group if you are not sure. Optional: the students can open the plants if you need to look more closely.
If you get done early, think of more plant parts that you eat to add to each box.

roots=carrot, parsnip, onion
stem=celery
leaves=spinach, lettuce
flowers=broccoli
fruit=red pepper, tomato, apple

Review what a fruit is, and how it is formed from a fertilized flower. Use the image from "The Reason for a Flower" book, or another image that shows the transition from a flower to a developing fruit.

Time lapse of a pear flowers becoming fruit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHHkmOh942A

Attached documents
Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 3
Gr 4

Fruit and vegetable search in art

Summary
Search for fruits and vegetables and other plants in Giuseppe Arcimboldo portraits.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Materials

1. Giuseppe Arcimboldo portrait for each table group
2. paper and pencil for each table group

Procedure

Study a portrait in groups and find and list as many fruit, vegetables, flowers as possible.
Report back to class on what each group finds.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 3

Butter

Summary
Make butter from cream. Discuss states of matter or colloids at each step.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Physical Science: Properties of Objects and Materials (grade K)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Materials
  • whipping cream, to fill each jar 1/3 way
  • jars to shake in, about one per 6 students
  • dixie cups for tasting buttermilk
  • plates for butter
  • salt to add to butter
  • knives to spread butter
  • crackers to eat butter on
Procedure

Add the whipping cream to each jar.
Students in a circle, shake the jar, then pass it on.
Shake until the cream is whipped (see first photo), then shake more to separate the fat and buttermilk (see second photo).
Pour out the buttermilk to taste.
Dump out the butter, add a little salt, and eat on bread or crackers.

For a lesson on states of matter, the students point out when they find a state during this activity, whether an ingredient or a new state from a reaction.
Discuss the changes in states of matter while making butter: start with a liquid (cream), which becomes a foamy solid (whipped cream), which then separates into a solid (butter) and a liquid (buttermilk).

For older students, work through the steps of how the molecules are arranged in the cream and butter.

For a lesson on mixtures, every step of this activity is a different type of colloid is formed:
Cream is an emulsion (drops of liquid fat in liquid water)
Whipped cream is a foam (air bubbles in the liquid cream)
Butter is a gel (liquid water droplets in solid fat)
See attached mixtures file for examples of other colloids, and other types of mixtures.

(Song used while shaking with younger students, to the tune of "Row, row, row your boat":
Shake, shake, shake the cream,
Shake it in a cup,
We are making butter now,
Then we'll eat it up)

Attached documents
Notes

Milk can be looked at under the transmission scope to see the fat droplets. Do the same for whipped cream and butter?

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Bread

Summary
Make bread and discuss the chemistry of it rising.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Needs of Living Things (grade 1)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Physical Science: Properties of Matter (grade 2)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Materials
  • kettle of boiling water
  • a sink
  • an oven at 350 degrees F

Per group of 3 or 4:

  • bowl
  • spoon
  • warm water (1/3 cup) - teacher can add
  • dry yeast (1 tspn) in container and tspn measure
  • Sugar (1/2 tspn) in container and 1/2 tspn measure
  • Salt (1/4 tspn) in container and 1/4 tspn measure
  • Flour (1 cup) in container and cup measure
  • Vegetable oil (1 tbspn) - teacher can add

Per student:

  • square of aluminium foil

For teacher:

  • marker to write names on foil
  • beaten egg in tub
  • brush
  • baking trays
  • oven glove
Procedure

For a lesson on states of matter, the students pointed out every time they found a different state during this activity, whether it is one of the ingredients or a new state made by a chemical reaction.

Make dough in groups of 3 or 4.
Teacher adds water to the bowl. Students add yeast, sugar and mix.
The yeast is a living thing and starts to eat the sugar.
Students add the salt, flour and mix.
Then use hands to knead the dough (stretch, fold and flatten, repeated).

Divide each dough ball into 3 or 4 pieces. Put a piece on each square of aluminum foil for each student.
The students knead some more, then mould into a shape (e.g. pretzel).

Talk about what is happening to the flour as it is kneaded: the flour has molecules in it that are made longer and longer as the dough is stretched, then folded over. They give the dough an elastic texture, that gives the finished bread the light texture.

Leave to rise for a few minutes - a gas is made by the ingredients that make the dough rise.
(During the wait another activity can be run. To isolate the ingredients that make gas do Yeast eats sugar and makes gas or test which ingredients make gas. To look at the chemistry that makes the bread rise, use molecule models to model the chemical reaction. See lesson plans for integrating the activities)

Review ingredients/chemical reaction of the bread rising:
What is yeast? A living thing. Breathes like us.
It eats sugar and releases gas bubbles into the dough.
The gas bubbles get stuck in the dough and makes it rise.

Put the bread in the oven:
Add name to each piece of foil.
Brush bread with egg and put in the preheated oven.
Bake at 350 degrees F for about 15 minutes, until brown on top. They may need turning/switching around in the oven.

While the bread is cooking, do another activity: make butter or use molecule models to show the chemical reaction happening between yeast and sugar. See the lesson plans for including these activities.

Before eating the bread, break it open to see the holes in it, made by the expanded gas bubbles in the dough.

Attached documents
Notes

Yeast is not a plant, but a fungus.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Cloud in a bottle

Summary
Make a cloud in a bottle (quite subtle).
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • Large wide-necked jar
  • Warm water (not hot)
  • Black paper
  • Tape
  • Ice cubes in a plastic bag
  • Matches (not a lighter)
Procedure

Tape the black paper to the back of the jar to create a dark background. This will make the cloud more visible.
Fill a third of the jar with warm water. If condensation forms on the inside of the jar, tip it up to clear it off with the water.
Light a match, blow it out, wait for a second or two, then drop the smoking match into the jar.
Quickly put the bag of ice on top of the jar, so it forms a cold lid over the opening.
Water vapour rising from the warm water condenses onto the smoke particles, and is visible as swirling clouds.
Lifting the ice bag releases the cloud.

This activity is not too dramatic, but does replicate exactly how a cloud forms. See the dry ice cloud for more dramatic demonstration.

Notes

Check Exploratorium activity:https://www.exploratorium.edu/snacks/fog-chamber
Good video of cloud in a jar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44GH2gs8avo

Grades taught
Gr 2

Weather Watcher

Summary
Excellent book of hands-on activities alongside well illustrated information on weather.
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Earth and Space Science: Surroundings (grade K)
Earth and Space Science: Daily and Seasonal Changes (grade 1)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Type of resource
Book
Resource details

Weather Watcher (DK Nature Activities series) by John Woodward. 2006. (Out of print)

Notes

Try the rainbow and lightning.