ingridscience

Sound through string

Summary
Listen to sounds through a solid: a piece of string. The sounds are quite different from the same sound coming through the air. Learn that different materials transmit sounds differently.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Physical Science: Light and Sound (grade 4)
Materials
  • Various household objects made of metal, plastic and wood. Vary the length and the size and the shape. Simple shapes are better that are made out of one piece. e.g. metal cutlery, wooden spoon and cooking implements, coat hangers (wire and plastic), key, chopsticks.
  • String, with a loop tied in the middle (so that it can be looped through each of the household objects)
Procedure

Show students how to secure the string to a chosen object so that it can hang freely, feeding the free ends of the string through the loop to hold it tightly if necessary.

Then wrap the free end of the string three turns around each index finger and push the finger against the flap of each ear (the tragus).
he ears are blocked so do not hear any sounds through the air, and the sounds coming up the string will be heard through the bones of the finger and the jaw.
(Practice with the string only at the carpet to check that students are pushing against the right part of their ear.)

Lean over and swing the object so that it bangs against a table or chair, which starts it vibrating. You only hear sounds coming up the string, through your finger and then through your jaw bone into your ear... and not through the air.

Students can anecdotally share their observations at the end, or use a worksheet (see attached below).

Questions to prompt students with experimentation:
What was the difference between objects made of different materials (e.g. plastic and metal)?
Try making the ringing sound, then touching the object or string to stop the ring.

After students have successfully heard some sounds through the string, ask them to compare with the sounds through the air. Swing and bang an object, but do not cover your ears.

What is happening?
As you bang the object it vibrates. The vibrations travel up the string to the bones in your ear, where you hear them as a sound that has passed only through solids. Different materials transmit vibrations differently and so the sound changes.

Objects that have a molecular structure that can vibrate and resonate more (i.e. metal) make a longer, ringing sound than plastic or metal.
Sounds through the string sound deeper and more resonant than sounds through the air, because the solids can transmit the lower frequencies (lower notes) than air.

To hear sound through another solid, lay your ear flat on a desk. Knock on the other end of the desk with your knuckles.

Animals hearing through different materials
Just as the sound is quite different through the string compared to through the air, animals that hear sounds through water or the ground hear sounds quite differently from us.

Sound travels faster and further through liquids (e.g. the ocean) and solids (e.g. the ground), than the air. But more energy is needed to transmit sounds through liquids and solids, so very quiet sounds do not transmit well.

Animals that hear sounds through the water:
Fish and marine mammals such as whales, dolphins. Lower frequencies travel well under water, and a long way.

Animals that hear sounds through the ground:
Snakes lack external ears and internal eardrums. They hear through their jaws (two jaws - can hear in stereo), the sound going directly to the cochlea. They bury themselves in sand to make their hearing more precise.
Elephants detect these seismic waves with the skin of their feet and trunk. Communicate danger from miles away.
Blind mole rat knocks its head against the walls of its tunnels to signal to its neighbors.
Termites in danger will bang their heads on the ground, which spreads like a chain reaction through the colony.
Kangaroo rats drum their foot on the ground with danger.
Frogs and spiders also hear through the ground.
https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/2013/11/14/good-vibrations-7-animal…

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Sound vibration model

Summary
Use a slinky (or a toy "space phone") to model how sound vibrations move in a wave. It can also show how light waves move.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Light and Sound (grade 4)
Materials
  • slinky, space phone, or other device with a long wire of tight coils
  • flat floor space (carpet OK)
Procedure

This models how sound travels by moving vibrations.

Pairs of students stretch the slinky (or space phone) between them on the ground.
At one end, quickly push the slinky to compress a few of the turns. The compression, if tight and fast enough, will move along the slinky.
See how the vibrations move along as a wave, as one part of the slinky pushes the next part.
This is how sound waves move: molecules bump the next molecules along, forming a wave of vibrations.
These are called longitudinal waves, and is how sound moves through solids, liquids and gases.

With the space phone the added cones mean that the sound of the coils vibrating are amplified, to make a strange, spacey sound.

Make a transverse wave by flicking the slinky quickly sideways. The wave will move along the slinky.
(This kind of wave is often easier for students to make.)
Light waves move in a transverse wave.

Look for the wave coming back along the slinky, which models an echo. An echo in a big room, or across a valley, is the sound waves bouncing back.

When these vibrating molecules reach our ear, they make our ear drum vibrate which transfers the energy vibrations to our inner ear where they stimulate neurons. The nerve fires and sends a signal to our brain, that we perceive as sound.

Grades taught
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5

Force stations

Summary
Students rotate through stations exploring different kinds of forces.
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Procedure

Set up a selection of the stations, and divide students into groups, to rotate through the stations.

For younger students, show what to do at each station, highlighting the forces in each case.
A good selection of Pushes and Pulls stations for Ks: balance point on a paint stick, balancing sculpture, magnetic race track, popsicle stick catapult

Older students can be told they will be exploring forces, and leave them to discover phenomena themselves.

Force stations relating to Playland amusement park rides:
Some stations have things spinning, like spinning rides - hand helicopters, spinning chair, also add a doodle top to make art.
One has a pendulum, like ’The Beast’ ride - spinning pendulum.
Also stations of hoopster in the hallway, and the balloon and hairdryer.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Balancing sculpture

Summary
Make a toothpick or grape balance on your finger or other object, by adding weight under it, which lowers the centre of mass to make it more stable.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Materials
    for a stick and styrofoam sculpture:
  • toothpicks
  • skewers or recycled thin sticks
  • pieces of styrofoam
  • modelling clay
    for a fruit/veg sculpture
  • grape, apple, potato etc
  • forks or other pointy utensils
Procedure

Activity video on YouTube.

Stick, clay and styrofoam sculpture
For older students, hand out the materials and challenge them to balance the toothpick on their finger. Show them that it is impossible with just a toothpick, but tell them that they have other materials to add to the toothpick to help them. Give them time to try. If necessary, give them clues that there needs to be most of the mass of their sculpture under the point of the toothpick, and then that the skewers can help to add the mass of the clay low down.
Encourage students to borrow each other's ideas, and that no idea is a bad idea. Encourage students to experiment with various configurations of the materials and see how their new models balance, or not (e.g. what happens if you remove one skewer, what happens if you change the position of the skewers, does it work without the clay at the end of the skewers?...) Tell them to try their sculptures on other things in the classroom.
For younger students show them how to make a simple sculpture: push the toothpick into the styrofoam, then add a skewer with a clay ball, as shown in the second photo. Ask them to try, then modify the sculpture if they like. Encourage students to balance their sculpture on other things in the classroom.

If pushed to one side, the sculpture can right itself.
The sculpture can be rocked back and forth.

Fruit sculpture
Quick to set up.
Try and balance the small end of a grape on your finger. It's pretty much impossible.
Add some mass below the grape, using forks, or other heavy objects, stuck into the grape at an angle.
If the forks are heavy enough an apple will work too.
A banana with a curve can be balanced on your finger if it curves downwards, as the curve puts some mass below the balance point, making it more stable.

Explanation in terms of force and centre of mass
The sculpture balances because the average position of all the mass ("the centre of mass") is underneath the balance point (the point of the toothpick). When gravity exerts a force on this centre of mass, it is pulling underneath the point of the toothpick (not above or to one side of it), therefore the toothpick is stable.
If the sculpture is tipped to one side, gravity pulls the weights back down to the lowest position, bringing the centre of mass below the toothpick once again. As long as the centre of gravity is below the balance point, any sculpture is stable.

Applications of this concept:
Engineers try to design a sports car's centre of gravity as low as possible to make the car handle better.
When high jumpers perform a "Fosbury Flop", they bend their body in such a way that it is possible for the jumper to clear the bar while his or her centre of mass does not.
When balancing on a beam, we stretch out our arms and move them around, to keep our centre of mass over our feet - not as stable as having the centre of mass below our feet, but better than having our arms by our side. Tightrope walkers have a long pole with weights on the end, which lowers their centre of mass, making them more stable.
Astronomical objects in motion are balanced around a centre of mass, forming stable coupled orbits (until a collision or other event moving one of them will make them realign around a new centre of mass).

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Spinning chair

Summary
Sit on a spinning chair with a weight in each hand. Draw your arms in and out to change your speed.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Materials
  • Swivel chair that can spin e.g. office chair
  • Two cans of food, or other heavy weights e.g. half bricks work well
Procedure

Sit in the chair.
Hold the cans in outstretched arms, and ask someone to start the chair spinning (or spin it with your feet). It does not need to be going super fast.
Bring your arms inwards, and feel yourself speed up.
Play around to experiment with the forces you are experiencing.

Explanation for younger students:
When the heavy cans change place, the speed of the chair spinning must also change. This is because the amount of force stays the same in the whole system (the chair, you and the cans). With arms outstretched a lot of force is needed to move the mass at the end of your arms, so there is less force to turn the chair. When your arms are pulled in it takes less force to move the weights, so more force can go into spinning the chair and it spins faster.

Explanation for older students:
A rotating object has a constant angular momentum (unless it is acted upon by an outside twisting force).
Angular momentum is the product of mass, the distance to the centre of the circle (radius), and angular velocity = vmr
When the mass is far from the centre of the circle, r is larger.
When the mass moves inwards, r gets smaller. As the mass is the same, the velocity must increase to keep the angular momentum the same.

Discussion on sports: this phenomenon is why an ice skater or a dancer doing a pirouette draw their arms and legs in to spin faster. Also used by divers or gymnasts when they go into a tuck position to flip or twist at a faster rate.

Notes

The same effect can be replicated without a chair: socks on a slippy floor allow you to turn well, and feel the force changing as you draw your arms in (and likely fall over!)

Grades taught
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6

Dancing magnets

Summary
A magnet on a string swings randomly and seemingly endlessly as it is attracted and repelled by other magnets. Can be used as a free experimentation activity.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Materials
  • string to hang magnet
  • magnet with a hole in it (if none available, the string can be taped to the magnet)
  • tape, to tape the string to a table top (or use clamp stand or support for hanging the magnet)
  • 3 other identical round/flat magnets
  • flat steel base, to attach the 3 magnets to e.g. tin plate, oven tray or upturned saucepan (or use the base of the clamp stand)
Procedure

Adapted from the Exploratorium snack https://www.exploratorium.edu/snacks/strange-attractor

Lay the 3 identical magnets in a triangle under the support.
Hang the hole magnet so it is suspended between these 3 magnets, and is attracted to them, but does not touch them.
Gently swing the suspended magnet so that it moves irratically between the other 3 magnets.
Adjust the height and position of the suspended magnet, and the positions of the other 2 magnets until you get best results - the suspended magnet can swing for quite a while before it finds a stable position.

Notes

Try doing with a really long string from the ceiling?

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6

Noise pollution game

Summary
Act out various ocean noise pollution to demonstrate how hard it is for animals (e.g. whales) to communicate with each other over noise pollution in the water.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Needs of Living Things (grade 1)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Life Science: Habitats and Communities (grade 4)
Materials
  • cards depicting different types of ocean animals and noise pollution e.g. blue whale, dolphin, cracking ice, ship engine. Enough for all students to have one, but only two or three students are ocean animals. Repeats are OK.
Procedure

Show all the students the different cards and demonstrate and practice the noise for each one.
Whale sounds can be found online, though note that often the sounds are played faster so that we can hear them
e.g. https://whalesound.ca/whales-and-sound/
e.g. http://www.nefsc.noaa.gov/psb/acoustics/sounds.html (This site indicates how much the sound is changed). The humpback and blue whale are the classic whale sounds.

Play one round with all students blue whales. They can hear each other's noises and respond to each other.
Then distribute all cards, and ask blue whales to find each other, with all the other noises going on - it is much harder.

This is what whales face with the increased noise pollution from man, along with the noise pollution already there from other natural phenomena e.g. ice cracking in their environment.

Notes

Game physically worked with Ks, but message lost on them. Fine with older grades.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 2
Gr 3