ingridscience

Flower colours

Summary
Mash a flower petal and change its colour to investigate how flowers make their different colours.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Materials
  • dark red rose. Many other dark pink/purple/red flowers also work e.g. dark red camellia, rhododendrons, red poppies. Bluebells work for adding acid, but make goopy petal juice
  • teaspoon measure
  • water
  • mortar and pestle (alternatively, smash the petals in a baggie)
  • pipette or dropper
  • tray with wells, white is best e.g. small paint tray (as pictured) or ice cube tray
  • vinegar in dropper bottle (or empty water bottle with a pin hole in the lid), labelled "acid"
  • baking soda (about 1 teaspoon) in water (about 1 cup) in dropper bottle, labelled "base"
  • optional: molecule models of acid and basic versions of cyanidin, or an image
Procedure

Please note that in a class of students it is likely that one of them is at least partially colourblind (1 in 12 males are colourblind). As this is an activity distinguishing colours, these students will not be able to tell some colours apart and perceive some colours differently, although the activity will be no less interesting for them. The common red/green colour blindness means reds and greens (or colours containing reds and greens such as browns) look similar. More information at colourblindawareness.org and colorblindguide.com/post/the-advantage-of-being-colorblind.

Pick a petal from the flower (use one rose petal, one camellia petal, 4 bluebell flowers, or equivalent).
Tear the petal into small pieces and put them in the mortar.
Add one teaspoon of water. Grind the petal and water together with the pestle: push down while grinding in a circle. Keep grinding until the water is as dark as the petal. It’s important that you get the water really dark.
(If you are not using a mortar and petal, tear the petal into pieces and put in a baggie with the water, then smash and squish the petal in the baggie until the petal juice is dark.)
Suck up the petal juice with a dropper. Put a few drops of petal juice in each well of the tray. Add a drop or two of acid (vinegar) to one well of the petal juice in the tray. Add a drop or two of base (baking soda solution) to another well. What new colours do you see? Are any of them familiar flower colours?
(acid makes the petal juice pink/orange; base makes it purple/blue (and green with some flowers).
Experiment with adding various amounts of acid and base to the petal juice.
Can you reverse the colour changes?

Ask students to record the changes they find, or visit the groups and record their results on one board (organizing the colours as they are reported). In class discussion, distill out the most frequent colour results in acid (oranges and pinks) and in base (blues and purples). White flowers can stay white in acid and turn yellow in base. Some colours will not change (generally yellows, oranges).

Just like you can make different colours by adding acid or base, some flowers are red, purple or blue depending on the levels of acid or base in their petals. They contain colour molecules (pigments) called anthocyanins that change structure slightly depending on the amount of acid or base they are in - one structure is red and the other is blue. Depending on the mix of red and blue anthocyanin molecules, the colour can vary between pink/red/purple/blue (all the colours you saw in the activity), giving rise to a great variety of flower colours from one kind of pigment molecule.

Optional - show students molecule models of red and blue anthocyanin molecules (I used the cyanidin molecule, which is the red pigment in dark red roses), and challenge them to find the difference between them. (Clue: look at the white hydrogen atoms.) One particular hydrogen atom on the cyanidin molecule is present in the acidic version of the molecule (which is red) and missing in the basic version (which is blue). Depending on the amount of acid or base, there is a different ratio of red and blue cyanidin molecules, which gives rise to the range of red-purple-blue colours.

You may have also made green petal juice. This is when, in base, one kind of pigment molecule (anthocyanin) turns blue and another pigment molecule (anthoxanthin) changes from white to yellow. When the yellow mixes with the blue anthocyanin, green results. If the colour changes are grouped on the board as they are gathered, the two kinds of pigment molecules can be seen separately and as mixtures in some kinds of flower petals.
Not all flower pigment molecules change with the amount of acid or base e.g. the yellow of tulips and other flowers. Pigment molecules mix and match together to make all the different flower colors that we see.

Students freely experimenting may also notice that bubbles sometimes form. If acid and base are added to the same well of the tray they chemically react to make CO2 gas (see baking soda chemistry).

Flowers attracting pollinators focus
By varying acidic/basic conditions in their petals, the anthocyanin molecules in flower petals make red, blue or purple colours. By mixing the anthocyanins with other colour molecules (e.g. yellow, orange), flowers can display a wide variety of colours. Different pollinators are attracted to different coloured flowers. See the flowers and insect pollinators activity. Some flowers even change colour as they age (e.g. the forget-me-not), indicating to pollinators they are past pollination time, so the pollinator will move to another flower which is ready for pollination.

Physical and Chemical Changes focus
Discuss how tearing and crushing the petal is a physical change. The shape has changed but it is still the same molecules of dye and water. Crushing the petal in water is a physical change: the dye moves from the petal into the water, but the molecules stay the same.
Ask students to look for chemical changes when they add acid and base to petals. Chemical changes are shown by: a change in colour, a change in smell or appearance of a gas. Students should find colour changes as the petals change colour in acid and base, as well as the appearance of a gas (when baking soda solution and vinegar are mixed together).

Notes

Simplify to just add acid to (bluebell) petal juice, then hunt for flowers with this new pink colour.
Try purple crocuses.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

DNA for a school assembly

Summary
Explanation of what DNA does in our bodies, for an assembly of primary or intermediate students.
Details about Theo refer to a student with Cornelia DeLange Syndrome.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Characteristics of Living Things (grade K)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Life Science: Human Body (grade 5)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Procedure

(Note: text marked with [] was omitted for primary students).

I’m going to talk about us - how we grew from a tiny dot. And about why do we all look different from each other. And why we all look like people, and not a cat or a tree.

(show image of DNA on overhead)
This stuff is the answer to all of these questions: DNA is the most amazing thing. You might have seen pictures of it before. There is DNA in every cell of our body - it is a spiral molecule. And it is the instructions to make our body. This is a billion times bigger than real DNA.

We all started as a tiny single cell. The DNA in that cell has instructions to tell the cell to [divide into more cells, and the instructions to tell those cells which to become back which to become front, then where to make a head, where to make a heart or an eye. Gradually, as more and more instructions are read, a human body] grows and develops into you.

(Show a petri dish of my DNA on overhead)
This is my DNA. I got from the cheek cells in my mouth. In that DNA is the instructions to make my body - my eye colour, my hair colour, why I need to wear glasses, even some of my personality. Your DNA looks the same on the outside, but when scientists look up close they see small differences between different peoples’ DNA. Those tiny differences are what make us all look different.
(Show image of DNA again and point out letters)

(Show hefty book of Shakespere)
If a book is the DNA instructions for a person, we need 100 of these books. Tiny parts of DNA are different between us, like spelling changes in words. That is why we look different. Most of our DNA instructions are the same, as we are all people, but those tiny changes are what makes us all look different.

A few of you have a change in your DNA that none of the rest of us have. Who here has red hair? I can show you exactly what change in the DNA makes your hair this colour - scientists have figured this out.
(Show sequence with one letter change in hair colour gene).
This is a part of a page in our book of DNA instructions. Can you find the one letter that is written in red? The rest of us have a G here. The redheads have a C here. This change in the instructions changes the colour of hair.

Theo has a change in his DNA that none of the rest of us has. Theo has a change to the instructions that tells the body how to grow. This change means that Theo is growing more slowly than the rest of us. Other people with the same DNA change as Theo also grow slowly and look like him. Only one in 10,000 people have the same DNA change as Theo.

Who has blue eyes? Another part of the DNA instruction book determines eye colour. You all have the same DNA letters in that part of the instructions and the rest of us have different instructions.

The only people that have the exact same DNA instructions are identical twins. Any identical twins here?

Everything about the way we look - our hair colour, how we develop, our eye colour, our height, also how we move, see, hear, eat, and talk is built from our DNA instructions. We are so complicated, that we can even think about ourselves thinking. It is absolutely mind boggling how complicated we are - and much of that complexity is built up from the instructions in our DNA. Life comes from this amazing molecule, DNA.

I've talked about our bodies and how we look like we do, but it's only part of the story. Now Theo's Dad will continue the story.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Chemistry of bacteria in cake

Summary
Students show what lactic acid bacteria does in a cake starter mix, by mixing together baking soda and vinegar.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Materials
  • Sugar molecule model
  • Small cups
  • Baking soda
  • Vinegar
  • Scoop (1/2 teaspoon)
  • Piece of Amish cake. Also other bread and cake (not essential)
Procedure

What about the bacteria in the starter mix?
It is a kind of bacteria that makes lactic acid from sugar. They eat sugar and make lactic acid.
Here are model molecules to show what happens. The bacteria eats the sugar and breaks it into this.
The acid made by the bacteria helps keep other bacteria and yeast away as they don’t like acid.
It also helps make more holes in the cake.

Lets do an activity to see what the lactic acid made by the bacteria does.
Put a scoop of baking soda in a cup.
One of the ingredients of the cake mixture was baking soda.
Pick up a cup of vinegar.
This is a acid like the acid made by the bacteria in the starter mixture.
Pick up your cup of baking soda, and a cup of vinegar. Keep them separate and take them back to your desk.
Once we are all sat down.... Just as in the cake recipe, with acid from the bacteria baking soda, pour the acid into the baking soda.
What happens (get bubbles).
The acid from the bacteria (which might make it smell as though the starter is off) and the baking soda we add to the recipe make gas bubbles. These get trapped in the batter and make the holes in the cake.

Grades taught
Gr 2
Gr 3

Chemistry of baking yeast cake

Summary
Experiments with yeast, then baking soda and vinegar show how gas is made while bread is made with a starter, and how they make the holes in the cake.
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Procedure

What is in the starter mix that we used for making sourdough bread or traditional bread/yeast cake?
Today we will investigate the living things that are in here, and what they do.

What living things could be in there? They must be small...
Living things in this starter are yeast and bacteria.
(There are some kinds of yeast and bacteria that make you sick, but there are plenty that are helpful to us, and these ones are helpful yeast and bacteria).
The yeast and bacteria in here live well together, and stop other yeasts or bacteria from growing.

Activity to determine the role of the yeast in the starter mixture.

Activity to determine the role of the bacteria in the starter mixture.

The starter has a yeast and a Lactobacillus bacteria in it.

Notes

A little much information for grade 2/3 class. Suggest either missing out the molecule models explaining what is going on (the yeast starts bubbling rapidly, so don't need much time waiting for it). Or just do one of the activities.

Grades taught
Gr 2
Gr 3

Yeast eats sugar and makes gas

Summary
Students observe yeast making carbon dioxide as it metabolizes (eats and breaks down) sugar.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Materials
  • Tall thin tubes e.g. 15ml tubes
  • Scoops (1/8 teaspoon)
  • Yeast
  • Sugar
  • Water (very warm to touch) in dropper bottles
  • Kettle to boil water, or tap with very hot water
  • Stir stick
  • Tube racks
  • Waste for stir stick
  • optional: flashlight to help visualize
  • Sugar molecule model
  • Piece of bread/yeast cake (or look at bread that students make)
Procedure

We will set up an activity to see what happens when yeast eats sugar.

Put a scoop of yeast and a scoop of sugar in at tube, then add warm water to half way up the tube.
Take a wooden stick and stir until the yeast and sugar have dissolved in the water. (What does that mean: solid to liquid).
Then put the tube in the tray on your desk.
We will leave the yeast for a while while we talk about what is happening in the tube.

The yeast is a living thing. It is dry or dormant in the jar, not doing anything. It can stay like that for a long time. When you add it to water and food it starts to eat.
The yeast eats the sugar you added to the tube. The yeast in the starter mixture of a yeast cake also eats sugar.

Yeast eats the sugar and breaks it down into carbon dioxide and ethanol.
(Show molecule models with older students.)
Ethanol is a kind of alcohol. For a bread recipe the ethanol does not stay around - it evaporates away. (When we make wine or beer with yeast, we keep the ethanol.)
Carbon dioxide - is it a gas, liquid or solid? It is a gas. We breathe it out. Yeast also breathes it out.
Your yeast should have activated by now and be making ethanol and carbon dioxide gas. What might the gas look like?

Hold your tube to the side and look for bubbles going up the side of the tube. Optional: use a flashlight to help find the bubbles. These are bubbles of carbon dioxide gas, made by the yeast as it eats the sugar you put in the tube. You might also see bubbles collecting at the top, making a kind of foam. Some of the tubes may even be spilling bubbles of gas over the top.
(If your parents make bread at home, you might have seen the same thing, in the bowl with the yeast and water at the beginning of the recipe.)

Optional: put a balloon over the tube, to collect the carbon dioxide gas and blow up the balloon.

Notes

Yeast is a fungus.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Pet cat demonstration

Summary
Pet cat wanders the classroom, while class discusses what kind of animal she is, her adaptations and survival.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Characteristics of Living Things (grade K)
Life Science: Needs of Living Things (grade 1)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Materials
  • Pet cat comfortable with people
  • Classroom that can be secured closed
  • Pet treats
    Procedure

    1. The cat wanders the classroom, during discussion of topics below

    CLASSIFICATION
    She is a mammal: Gives birth to live babies. Feeds her babies her milk.
    She is a carnivore.
    Similarities and differences between Maggie and other animals (tigers, lions, other wild cats)

    LIFE CYCLE
    Maggie is an adult, 4.5 years old.
    That is like a human being 34 years old
    (1 human year is 15 cat years, 2 human years is 24 cat years, 3 human years is 28 cat years… plus 4 for each year).

    BEHAVIOUR
    Hissing and bushy tail = fighting
    Purring = happy
    Upright tail = friendly
    Flicking tail and ears back = annoyed, stay away
    Ears forward = interested

    SURVIVAL
    What does Maggie need for survival? She has it pretty good: food, water, shelter.
    What about wild cats?

    2. Students sit in a circle and take turns to either pet her or feed her a treat.

    Grades taught
    Gr 1
    Gr 2

    Magnets: paper clip bridge

    Summary
    Students make a bridge of paper clips between two magnets. The materials can be used as a free experimentation activity.
    Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
    Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
    Materials
    • Two magnets per student
    • 20 or so paper clips per student, or better small nails (which can't be hooked together)
    Procedure

    Students make a bridge out of paper clips/nails between two magnets.
    What is the longest bridge you can make?
    Does it help to have the paper clips/nails piled up or in single file?

    Discussion:
    See that magnetic force can pass through the paper clips.
    Some metals can become magnets and attract another metal.

    Grades taught
    Gr 1
    Gr 2

    Magnetic force field patterns

    Summary
    Students use iron filings to visualize the direction of the magnetic field lines and the shape of magnetic fields around various magnets. Can be used as a free experimentation activity. Can also be used to introduce magnetic field lines of the Sun.
    Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
    Earth and Space Science: Stars and Planets (grade 3)
    Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
    Materials
    • various magnets (round, bar, fridge magnets)
    • iron filings sealed in a clear food container (e.g. salad/herb container) - use hot glue around the edges to seal, then shake to check for leaks; leave the white label on to show the patterns better. Alternatively, a large petri dish; attach a white label to the bottom to make the patterns show up better (though a thick label blocks some weak magnetic fields of fridge magnets)
    Procedure

    Before the class, prepare the iron filing container: sprinkle 1/4 teaspoon of iron filings into a larger salad container or 1/8 teaspoon into a small herb container. Apply a line of hot glue around the container edge and quickly seal shut. After a minute of cooling time, shake the iron filings around the sides of the container to locate any leaks, then seal these with more hot glue.

    Each student experiments with moving magnets under the iron filings to see the patterns they make.
    The shape of the magnetic field can be drawn with lines, that follow the lines that the iron filings make.

    Discussion:
    The patterns show how the force of the magnet spreads out around it.
    Different magnets have different force field shapes.

    For a lesson on the sun, this activity can be used to introduce how magnets have magnetic field lines around them.
    The sun has very complex patterns of magnetic field lines, because of how the magnetic fields are formed within the sun:
    Magnetic fields in the sun are made by the moving charged particles of the plasma particles which make up the sun. (Plasma is a fourth state of matter, more energetic than a gas, which exists in the very hot, high pressures of the sun).
    The sun's plasma forms moving magnetic fields within the sun, which also loop outwards from it.
    Show the field lines with this image: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_width_feature/publ…
    The immense magnetic fields of the sun pull loops of gas from the sun and out along the field lines.
    Amazing movie at: https://sdo.gsfc.nasa.gov/assets/gallery/movies/Active_Regions_linkage_…
    and even more amazing close ups at: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_width_feature/publ… and https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_width_feature/publ…
    Image of a prominence including the earth to scale: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_width_feature/publ…
    The Sun’s magnetic field lines sometimes twist so much that they “snap”, sprawling prominences (hot loops of plasma) into space. The plasma that does escape streams away from the sun as solar winds, filling the heliosphere which extends beyond the solar system.

    Sunspots (darker regions on the surface of the Sun) are caused by strong magnetic fields blocking heat from the centre of the sun.
    Larger sunspots are larger than earth.

    Grades taught
    Gr K
    Gr 1
    Gr 2
    Gr 3
    Gr 4
    Gr 5
    Gr 6
    Gr 7

    Magnetic fishing game

    Summary
    Students try to pick up fish with magnets. The fish have different kinds of metal at their mouths so some won't catch. Can be used as a free experimentation activity.
    Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
    Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
    Materials
    • Paper cut-out fish, each with a paper clip, staple, safety pin (all steel) or aluminum foil strip at their mouth. Several of each kind for each student.
    • Magnet on a string, attached to a rod, for each student
    Procedure

    Students catch fish, and figure out which ones won't be caught by the magnet.

    Discussion:
    The paper clip and staple fish mouths have iron in them, so are attracted to the magnet.
    The aluminum is not attracted to magnets, so these fish cannot be caught.

    Notes

    Alternatively, use a commercial magnetic fishing puzzle.

    Grades taught
    Gr K
    Gr 1
    Gr 2

    Magnets: what sticks to them?

    Summary
    Students use magnets to try and pick up various materials. Can be used as a free experimentation activity.
    Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
    Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
    Materials
    • magnets, one per student
    • materials to test, some metal, some of those containing iron. e.g. iron nail, brass screw, aluminum foil, paper clip, wood, coin, pipe cleaner, eraser, paper, copper item e.g. cookie cutter
    • non-metal trays to spread materials out in
    Procedure

    Students record which materials are attracted to a magnet and which are not, and try to find any patterns in their observations.

    Discussion:
    Only iron (steel contains iron), also nickel and cobalt, are attracted to magnets.
    With older students, maybe discuss how the electrons inside the atoms are aligned when something is magnetic.
    Some rocks are naturally magnetic.

    Notes

    We found that some pennies were attracted to the magnet and some were not. An interesting extension would be to collect many pennies, and look for a correlation between the year the penny was made and whether they are attracted to a magnet, to predict what metals are in each year.

    Grades taught
    Gr K
    Gr 1
    Gr 2
    Gr 3