ingridscience

Plant colour chemistry and pH indicators

Summary
Change flower petal colours with acid/base and use red cabbage as an acid/base indicator.
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Life Science: Plant Growth and Changes (grade 3)
Physical Science: Chemistry (grade 7)
Procedure

Some flowers can change colour depending on the chemical environment they are in.
Do flower colour activity.
Discuss what colours were made, and the molecules responsible.
Flowers can make an array of petal colours by varying the acidic/basic environment (the concentration of H atoms) in their petals. This changes the colour of some pigment molecules, and several pigment molecules can mix to make even more colours.

Chemists often use a pigment that changes colour with acid and base to find out how many H atoms are in something. They call it an indicator.
The scale of how acidic or basic something is can be measured on a scale called the pH scale. So these indicators are called pH indicators.
Make a pH indicator with cabbage juice, and use to measure the pH of household chemicals.

Test fruits and vegetables that are red, blue and purple to find out which ones have pH sensitive pigments.

The concentration of H atoms (technically ions), or the pH, affects the chemistry of many systems, as it affects what chemical reactions happen and what molecules are made. pH is important in water and soil, changing how plants get nutrients and grow, and what minerals are dissolved and precipitated; it is important in our own bodies to make sure we digest food and make new cells for growth and to heal injuries.

Notes

Laurier did flower colours and red cabbage dye.
ingridscience afterschool did red cabbage dye and fruit and vegetable colours.
The colouring a white flower activity was added to this lesson plan for a lesson on Coloured plants for After school programs in NY.
Seymour did red cabbage dye, then vegetable colours

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Chemical reactions

Summary
Do two activities from the selection, to show chemical reactions. Choose food-related ones for a Chemistry of Cooking / Foods workshop.
Procedure

Pair two or three activities for a lesson.
Include molecule models for older primaries and up.

A chemical reaction happens when we see a new product: a new state of matter (e.g. gas bubbles or a solid precipitating), or a new colour or smell.

Examples of combinations:

1 Elephant's toothpaste demonstration - see a new state of matter and feel the temperature change.
Baking soda demonstration - see a new state of matter and feel the temperature change.
Molecular modelling of baking soda and vinegar.
Rocket outside or Soda drink

2 Soda drink
Molecular modelling of chemistry
Rocket outside with same chemistry
Cleaning pennies

3 Baking powder chemistry
Molecular modelling of chemistry
Rocket outside with same chemistry

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Water resistance: racing shapes through water

Summary
Move different shapes through water with a weight, to compare their speeds, and so how streamlined they are. Compare to the shapes of animals that move through the water.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Life Science: Needs of Living Things (grade 1)
Life Science: Animal Growth and Changes (grade 2)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Materials
  • tray of water. 5cm deep or more means the shapes do not bump along the bottom too much
  • two medium binder clips (to attach to the side of the tray)
  • fishing line
  • four small binder clips
  • modelling clay, two different colours (one strip from a dollar store pack for each colour; I find about 10-12g works well so that wider shapes do not bump along the bottom)
  • 2 little bags or pots to hold marbles
  • about 10 marbles
  • chopstick
Procedure

Set up:

Cut a piece of fishing line a little longer than the tray.
Remove one arm (handle) from a mini binder clip, tie one end of the line to its remaining arm, and wrap modelling clay around the body of the binder clip. (Left of first photo.)
Thread the fishing line through the arms of the medium binder clip, then tie the free end to the other mini binder clip.
Attach a little pot to this mini binder clip.
See the first image for the result of these steps. Make two of these for one tray.

Half fill the tray with water, then attach the fishing line/clay unit at one end with its medium binder clip.
Allow the pot of marbles to hang down so that its weight pulls the clay up to the medium binder clip.
See the second image.
Attach the second unit next to the first.

Experiment:
Make two different shapes from two pieces of clay in the same tray.
Pull them both to the end of the tray and release at the same time. Using a chopstick as a gate can be used to hold the lines, then release them at exactly the same time.
Do 3 trials, to see which shape usually moves through the water fastest and which is slowest.

Discussion:

In general, in the activity, wider shapes move more slowly than narrower longer 'streamlined' shapes.
Compare to objects that we build to be streamlined and move faster through water e.g. boats, and objects that do not need to be streamlined e.g. rubber ring for floating in water.
Also look at shapes of fish (an image of fish shapes in silhouette is useful for reference). The fish that can move the fastest (e.g. fish that hunt live prey, like salmon) have longer, narrower shapes than those that do not need to move fast (e.g. fish that feed on plants or algae or are flat on the bottom).

Optional: give local fish examples and how their shape is an adaptation for how they eat and move. Examples of British Columbia fish:
herring (streamlined to escape predators - larger fish. eat tiny animals)
salmon (streamlined to swim through fast moving water, escape predators and to catch smaller fish)
sole (not streamlined - do not move fast; flattened to hide from larger fish that eat it. eat worms clams)
sculpin (not streamlined - do not move much; camouflaged to hide from predator fish. eat insects)

Optional: Watch a video showing various fish shapes moving through the water e.g. Planet Earth video of fish in the ocean of various shapes. Try this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4XXJs6vCTzc&list=PL8B8EDD0D02DA14B7

Attached documents
Notes

Visualize using technique in turbulence patterns. Difference between streamlined and non-streamlined shapes.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5

Combustion shooter

Summary
Project a ping pong ball by igniting hair spray.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Materials
  • paper towel tube
  • ruler
  • BarBQ lighter
  • duct tape
  • hairspray with flammable ingredients e.g. alcohol, propane or butane
  • ping pong ball (should fit snugly inside the paper towel tube)
Procedure

Cover the end of the paper towel tube with duct tape.
Cut a small hole in the duct tape the same diameter as lighter nozzle, push the lighter through so about 6cm extends inside the tube. Tape over any gaps and secure the lighter.
Bridge the ruler between the paper towel tube and the lighter, to strengthen the device.

To fire: spray some hairspray into the paper towel tube, drop in a ping pong ball, then ignite the lighter.

The device works by a combustion reaction: the alcohol combines with the oxygen in air and is converted to CO2(gas) and water. The reaction is started by the energy of the lighter, and then can continue on its own. More and more gas is made in the confined space behind the ping pong ball, until the pressure of the gas is enough to shoot the ball forward.

Grades taught
Gr 4
Gr 6

Filtering Water

Summary
Make a water filter from a recycled water bottle and use various materials to filter muddy water.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Renewable and Non-Renewable Resources (grade 5)
Materials
    for the filter units (ideally one per student) and set up:
  • water bottles, cut in half
  • panty hose/nylons squares, 5x5cm
  • small elastic bands
  • tubs of muddy pond water (1 cup dirt in a litre of water)
  • ~half cup measures
  • wash bottles and waste tub to rinse out filters between trials
  • bucket for overflow waste (do not put sand and gravel down the sink)
    filter materials (in order of 2nd and 3rd photos):
  • coffee filters
  • washed moss balls (optional)
  • kleenex
  • [no material: control]
  • wood shavings
  • cotton balls
  • washed aquarium sand + spoon
  • washed aquarium gravel + spoon (optional)
Procedure

Set up before lesson:
Cut recycled water bottles in half and discard cap.
Cut a square of panty hose/nylons and use a small elastic band to secure over the spout of the water bottle.
Ideally, make one filter per student.
Mix a cup of soil with water in several large tubs.

Introduction:
Where do we get our drinking water? [Tap.] Where does this water come from? [Reservoirs.] It is cleaned to be safe.
Indigenous people and others living off the land would get their water from natural water sources such as fast flowing streams. This is usually OK, if water is taken well away from toilets (most common source of dangerous microorganisms).

We will filter muddy water through some different materials to see how well they can clean it.
Show students the filter, how to pour and show them the materials selection (depending on age group):
e.g. coffee filter, moss, kleenex, wood chips, cotton balls, washed sand, washed gravel
e.g. Kindergarten: washed sand, cotton balls, filter paper and tissue
For older students, discuss setting up a control, where the filter has no material added.
Show students the worksheet, where they can record the colour of the emerging water (see worksheet attachments).

Encourage students to try one filter material at a time, before showing them how to layer filter materials, or stack up the filter units, to make the water cleaner.
Free play will happen naturally, but encourage note-taking so that students know what works best.
If students need encouragement: ask them to try different filter combinations that are all natural/one kind repeated to see if this cleans the water better.

Class discussion of results:
Ask how good each material was for filtering water when used alone, and make a class chart. (The results will vary widely, so use the chart to show the best that each material did.) Discuss how the materials filter the water: the dirt particles are trapped in the tiny spaces between the filter material. The water flows through, along with anything that can fit through the spaces. Different materials have different sized spaces, so are effective at filtering different sized dirt particles. Materials that clean the water better have smaller spaces in them, but the water takes longer to pass through them.
Then students will be keen to tell how their different combinations of materials worked.

Connect to water treatment plants:
For younger students they can be told that water treatment filtering systems that clean our water also use sand and gravel. They use several filters and use other membranes as well.
For older students discuss how sand and gravel are arranged in water treatment filtering systems, and that filtering is just one step that our water treatment facilities use. They use gravel and sand to remove larger particles, and meshes to remove smaller particles. Here is the multistep process:
1. aeration to remove gases from water
2. coagulation to clump together dirt (floc)
3. sedimentation allows floc to fall to bottom of settling beds
4. filtration to remove particles (several filters including meshes, sand and gravel)
5. disinfection with chlorine to kill remaining pathogens (ozone and UV treatment do not persist)
See http://www.agr.gc.ca/eng/science-and-innovation/agricultural-practices/…

More info on filtering water, naturally and by man:
https://sciencing.com/natural-materials-used-water-filtration-5371122.h…

Notes

It is important to wash the sand and gravel before-hand; otherwise the dirt contained in it will dirty the water.

Experiment with more steps of water filtration process: https://www3.epa.gov/safewater/kids/grades_4-8_water_filtration.html

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5

Rain gauge model - tipping bucket

Summary
Rain gauges in weather stations use a tipping bucket (or tipping spoon) mechanism. Challenge students to make their own tipping bucket for a marble.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Daily and Seasonal Changes (grade 1)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • optional: water bottle rain gauge for showing
  • optional: tipping spoon part of weather station with water to demonstrate
  • Per small group:

  • plastic spoon
  • skewer, cut into 3
  • piece of straw, 2cm, that skewer fits snugly into
  • masking tape, small strip
  • popsicle sticks, 2
  • cup (coffee or pastic)
  • marble
  • for teacher:

  • wire [skewer/pop stick] cutters
Procedure

Your classic rain gauge that you might have made from a water bottle is very simple, but fills up.

A tipping bucket rain gauge uses electronics to count the number of times a bucket fills and empties, so can be left to run for long periods.
A funnel above the tipping bucket directs rainfall into it. The volume of water in the bucket is known, so if you can count the number of times it tips, you can calculate the amount of water.
See a gif of a tipping bucket rain gauge here: https://www.yoctopuce.com/EN/article/how-to-build-an-usb-pluviometer

Students design their own tipping bucket mechanism with household materials, and use a marble dropped into the bucket to make it work.

Start like this: insert skewer in straw piece, tape onto spoon at the balance point, making sure it can rotate freely. Secure to cup with clay. It’s like a see saw. We have the rotation part. This pivot is one design element of a tipping bucket.
You are going to design the rest. You will be using a marble instead of water. It needs to start horizontally, tip down when the marble falls in the spoon to dump the marble out, then returns quickly to the horizontal position. (Demonstrate the steps.)
What other design elements will it need? Write up any that they come up with e.g. weight, stop - but do not add more than they can think of as they will discover more as they work.
Students can break the materials apart if they need, and take more of anything.

Once the students have made their designs, ask what other design elements are needed.
Complete the list of design elements:
pivot, weighted lever, stops to limit movement.

The tipping bucket rain gauge in a weather station is finely weighted, balanced and housed so that it works as your models do.
It uses a magnet to hold the bucket until it is heavy enough to tip. A circuit detects when the bucket tips, and counts the number of times, to calculate total rainfall over time.

Grades taught
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Weather - measuring weather

Summary
Build devices that model measurement of rainfall and wind speed. Make a simple barometer. Use thermometers
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Procedure

We can predict what weather is coming, and see weather patterns over time by taking measurements.
What kind of things might we measure? Hint: what is reported on the weather news?
Temperature (Cold and warm air fronts on a weather map - air masses of different temperatures moving around. Temperature can affect the type of precipitation that forms - rain, snow or hail (warm then cold layer of air in the atmosphere make rain which freezes into hail). If the air layers are dry enough, the moisture may evaporate before reaching the ground.)
Rainfall
Wind: Direction and speed tells us what is coming
Air (or barometric) pressure: Low pressure means clouds are coming. High pressure means clear skies are coming.
Humidity: How much water is in the air. That and temperature determines if it precipitates.

Make devices that measure weather, or model weather-measuring devices. Optionally, take the materials outdoors to measure weather conditions.
Optional: look at a real weather station to find the parts that do the measuring.

Primaries use thermometers to measure temperature. (Look at radiation shield in a weather station where the digital thermometer is housed.)
Intermediates are challenged to model a tipping spoon rain gauge.
Intermediates make a barometer.
Challenge for everyone to build a device that turns in the wind.

Notes

Add Wind vane to this lesson.
This is the third of a series of Weather lessons: 1. Weather - What causes it? 2. Weather phenomena 3. Measuring weather

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Clouds, tornado and vortices with dry ice

Summary
Use dry ice to show how clouds form. Use your hands to create upwards spinning vortices, modelling tornados. Use a bottle to make horizontally spinning vortices to model a microburst.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • dry ice in insulted container - 10 pellets/100 pellets per class
  • gloves to handle dry ice
  • black bin bag
  • masking tape
  • shallow tub
  • kettle for boiling water
  • recycled water bottle with flexible sides
Procedure

Distribute black bin bags, and ask students to tape over desk.

Distribute shallow tub and bottle containing very warm water. Add dry ice (2 pellets).

The following activities can be done with more or less emphasis on the weather phenomenon they are modelling.

Ask what weather phenomenon they have made. Cloud. Water vapour in the air cools to form water droplets.
(How dry ice makes this: super cold, becomes a gas at -80°C. The water vapour in the air (from the warm water in the tub), cools and condenses among the cold CO2 gas.)

Add more dry ice and hot water to the tub, then demonstrate making tornados: hold hand flat and upright within the cloud spilling out of the tub, then lift up fast. (Too tricky for most Ks, but they like to watch.) Watch this video to see how it's done (though not with the same equipment): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yc-jNvNucQ4
The spinning air mass of a tornado is called a vortex. The air rotates around the funnel shape.
A real tornado is one of the most powerful forces on earth - winds up to 500km/hr.
They form when warm, moist air meets cool air and they start to spin. The air spirals up into a thundercloud. The low pressure inside (from fast winds) cools the air which condenses into a cloud.

Another weather feature is also a vortex but spins in a ring: called a microburst.
A microburst is formed when cold air descends to the ground fairly fast, then hits the ground and spins away in a ring.
This kind of vortex can be modelled with a pellet of dry ice inside a little warm water in a recycled water bottle. Squeeze and release the water bottle quickly and gently. It seems to work better as the dry ice bubbling subsides a little.

Notes

Scale up the vortex to make an air cannon.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Blue sky red sunset colours

Summary
Use a glue stick and flashlight to model why the sky is blue and sunsets are red.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Daily and Seasonal Changes (grade 1)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • glue stick
  • flashlight
Procedure

Knowing sunlight is a mixture of colours, we can figure out why the sky is blue, and sunsets are red.
Distribute glue sticks and flashlights.
Tell students the glue stick models our atmosphere. and the flashlight is the sun.
Challenge them to shine the "sun" through the "atmosphere" and look for a blueish sky colour, and a red-orange sunset colour.

Explanation:
Blue: Sunlight hits the atmosphere and is scattered in all directions (O2 and N2). Blue light is scattered more than other colours, so more blue reaches our eyes from all parts of the sky.
Red: As the sun gets low in the sky, its light passes through more atmosphere to reach you. Most of the blue light is scattered, so only reds/yellows reach your eyes.

Notes

Or add a little milk to water, and shine a flashlight through it to see the blue colour. Add more milk to see the red/orange colour. (Weather Watcher p.60. DK)

Grades taught
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7