ingridscience

Weather - measuring weather

Summary
Build devices that model measurement of rainfall and wind speed. Make a simple barometer. Use thermometers
Curriculum connection (2005 science topic)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Procedure

We can predict what weather is coming, and see weather patterns over time by taking measurements.
What kind of things might we measure? Hint: what is reported on the weather news?
Temperature (Cold and warm air fronts on a weather map - air masses of different temperatures moving around. Temperature can affect the type of precipitation that forms - rain, snow or hail (warm then cold layer of air in the atmosphere make rain which freezes into hail). If the air layers are dry enough, the moisture may evaporate before reaching the ground.)
Rainfall
Wind: Direction and speed tells us what is coming
Air (or barometric) pressure: Low pressure means clouds are coming. High pressure means clear skies are coming.
Humidity: How much water is in the air. That and temperature determines if it precipitates.

Make devices that measure weather, or model weather-measuring devices. Optionally, take the materials outdoors to measure weather conditions.
Optional: look at a real weather station to find the parts that do the measuring.

Primaries use thermometers to measure temperature. (Look at radiation shield in a weather station where the digital thermometer is housed.)
Intermediates are challenged to model a tipping spoon rain gauge.
Intermediates make a barometer.
Challenge for everyone to build a device that turns in the wind.

Notes

Add Wind vane to this lesson.
This is the third of a series of Weather lessons: 1. Weather - What causes it? 2. Weather phenomena 3. Measuring weather

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Clouds, tornado and vortices with dry ice

Summary
Use dry ice to show how clouds form. Use your hands to create upwards spinning vortices, modelling tornados. Use a bottle to make horizontally spinning vortices to model a microburst.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • dry ice in insulted container - 10 pellets/100 pellets per class
  • gloves to handle dry ice
  • black bin bag
  • masking tape
  • shallow tub
  • kettle for boiling water
  • recycled water bottle with flexible sides
Procedure

Distribute black bin bags, and ask students to tape over desk.

Distribute shallow tub and bottle containing very warm water. Add dry ice (2 pellets).

The following activities can be done with more or less emphasis on the weather phenomenon they are modelling.

Ask what weather phenomenon they have made. Cloud. Water vapour in the air cools to form water droplets.
(How dry ice makes this: super cold, becomes a gas at -80°C. The water vapour in the air (from the warm water in the tub), cools and condenses among the cold CO2 gas.)

Add more dry ice and hot water to the tub, then demonstrate making tornados: hold hand flat and upright within the cloud spilling out of the tub, then lift up fast. (Too tricky for most Ks, but they like to watch.) Watch this video to see how it's done (though not with the same equipment): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yc-jNvNucQ4
The spinning air mass of a tornado is called a vortex. The air rotates around the funnel shape.
A real tornadoes is one of the most powerful forces on earth - winds up to 500km/hr.
They form when warm, moist air meets cool air and they start to spin. The air spirals up into a thundercloud. The low pressure inside (from fast winds) cools the air which condenses into a cloud.

Another weather feature is also a vortex but spins in a ring: called a microburst.
A microburst is formed when cold air descends to the ground fairly fast, then hits the ground and spins away in a ring.
This kind of vortex can be modelled with a pellet of dry ice inside a little warm water in a recycled water bottle. Squeeze and release the water bottle quickly and gently. It seems to work better as the dry ice bubbling subsides a little.

Notes

Scale up the vortex to make an air cannon.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Blue sky red sunset colours

Summary
Use a glue stick and flashlight to model why the sky is blue and sunsets are red.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Daily and Seasonal Changes (grade 1)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • glue stick
  • flashlight
Procedure

Knowing sunlight is a mixture of colours, we can figure out why the sky is blue, and sunsets are red.
Distribute glue sticks and flashlights.
Tell students the glue stick models our atmosphere. and the flashlight is the sun.
Challenge them to shine the "sun" through the "atmosphere" and look for a blueish sky colour, and a red-orange sunset colour.

Explanation:
Blue: Sunlight hits the atmosphere and is scattered in all directions (O2 and N2). Blue light is scattered more than other colours, so more blue reaches our eyes from all parts of the sky.
Red: As the sun gets low in the sky, its light passes through more atmosphere to reach you. Most of the blue light is scattered, so only reds/yellows reach your eyes.

Notes

Or add a little milk to water, and shine a flashlight through it to see the blue colour. Add more milk to see the red/orange colour. (Weather Watcher p.60. DK)

Grades taught
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Rainbow with water and flashlight

Summary
Shine a flashlight through water at just the right angle to make a (subtle) rainbow.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Surroundings (grade K)
Earth and Space Science: Daily and Seasonal Changes (grade 1)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • jar half filled with water
  • flashlight
  • white sheet of paper
Procedure

Distribute glass of water, flashlight and white paper to each student or student pair.
Ask them: We have water and sunlight. What weather feature might we make?
Once they know they are looking for a rainbow, older students can be challenged to arrange the flashlight, jar and paper to make a rainbow, while younger students can be assisted in making one:
Hold the jar in the air just above the desk. Lay the paper down in front of the jar. Shine the flashlight at the water line from back a bit, maybe angling it downwards a little. Don't block the bottom edge of the jar with your fingers. The higher the jar, the wider the rainbow. If you tip the jar slightly, you can make multiple rainbows.

Grades taught
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Weather phenomena

Summary
Model different kinds of weather to understand how they are formed: rainbows, blue skies, red sunsets, frost and dew, lightning, clouds, tornados.
Procedure

Intermediates set up frost cans to revisit later.
Push to the end of the table, where they will not be touched.

Introduction:
What kinds of weather can you think of?
Today we will make some mini versions of weather phenomena in the classroom, to see how they come about.

Rainbow.
Kindergarten instead made rainbows with CDs etc.
Discuss how the sun shining through water droplets makes rainbows in the same way. With your back to the sun they appear in front of you.

Blue sky and red sunsets activity.
(Kindergarten skipped)

Frost can revisit with intermediates:
What do you see? How did it get there? Dew. Frost. If these had formed up in the air, what would they be? Rain/snow/hail. Dew in the desert is critical for some plants and animals, that collect it on their leaves and bodies.

Lightning (with intermediates)

Clouds and tornados.
Added bottle vortices if time.

Summary:
Weather phenomena are caused by water in the air, temperature differences that make air move around, and pressure differences that move air and make water condense. By mixing and matching these three things in different amounts, we get all kinds of weather phenomena.

Notes

This is the second of a series of Weather lessons: 1. Weather - What causes it? 2. Weather phenomena 3. Measuring weather

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Wind spinner free experimentation

Summary
Use common materials to design and construct a device that turns in the wind. Relate to an anemometer (which measures wind speed) or wind turbines/windmills.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Daily and Seasonal Changes (grade 1)
Earth and Space Science: Air, Water and Soil (grade 2)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Earth and Space Science: Renewable and Non-Renewable Resources (grade 5)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Materials and Structures (grade 3)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Materials
  • scissors
  • masking tape
  • cardboard e.g. cereal boxes
  • skewers
  • popsicle sticks or coffee stir sticks
  • straws
  • little tubes or pen caps
  • optional: push pins
  • optional: other blunt pins (mine came out of a broken pin screen)
  • optional: modelling clay (recommended after the pivot has been built)
Procedure

Show students the materials.
Give them their challenge:
Make a device that turns in the wind. For older students add that it could be used for measuring how fast the wind is going.
They can test their device by blowing on it, or ideally, by taking it into/making it in the wind outside.

For older students, allow them to work a while, then state the key design components:
(to help students that are still to start on a design, and to conceptually frame designs already in progress)
A pivot: parts that can spin around each other.
"Blades" that can catch the wind: larger surface areas that the wind can hit and push against.
It might be useful for them to refer back to these if they get stuck in their designing.

For some student groups this activity may be best split up into two parts. First all students make a pivot, then share each others’ designs. Then students choose any of the pivot styles displayed, make their own pivot and design blades to attach to their pivot.

Show younger or less mechanically-minded students different ideas for making a pivot (there are many other ways):
1. a skewer in an inverted tube/pen cap (to which the blades can be attached)
2. a skewer through a straw (to which the blades can be attached)
3. a blunt pin through an enlarged hole in a straw
There are other ways to make a pivot, but these are the simplest.

For Kindergarten students, provide them with tube-and-skewer pivot, cardboard, scissors and tape. Demonstrate how the tube spins on the skewer. Draw and name shapes that they could cut out of cardboard ("rectangle", "triangle", "blade shape" good to include), to tape to the tube. They can add more shapes if they want. Depending on how they tape the blades onto the tube, and so how floppy the blades are, they may need to be shown how to strap a strip of curved cardboard across two blades to hold them steady.

Allow students time to freely experiment, discuss ideas together (and "steal" good ideas from each other, as all good designers and architects do).
The Play-Debrief-Replay method for teaching works well for this activity - see notes in the resource.

If students are in need of help, either ask them to visit other wind machines that are spinning in the classroom, or help them focus on some ideas (e.g. see pivot ideas above).

Once they are done experimenting, review the different ways of making the key machine elements (pivot; blades to catch the wind)

During discussion, refer to uses of wind machines:
Anemometers measure wind speed - cups that spin around a shaft. Using magnets, the number of turns is translated into wind speed. (Show real anemometer if possible.)
Other applications of machines that turn in the wind:
(Wind vanes have a blade that turns in the wind, but its position stablilizes to show the direction that the wind is coming from.)
Windmills are wind machines used to pump water for farming or for groundwater extraction. They were also commonly used for grinding grain. They are complex machines of levers, wheels and gears.
A wind turbine is a windmill used to generate electricity: the energy in wind turns a blade which runs a generator to make electricity. Wind turbines are in greater use with increasing sustainable energy practices.

Notes

I started out also providing little paper cups in the materials, but found that students did not use them as the part that catches the wind, but often as a rickety pivot. Removing the cups redirected students towards better pivot ideas, and if they wanted a cup-like blade, they could curve the cardboard or paper.
I started out providing clay, but students often stuffed the little tube with it to try and make an (ineffective) pivot. Now I only provide it after pivots are made and if asked for, or if deemed useful for making a stand or for cementing parts together.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Barometer

Summary
Make a simple barometer to measure air pressure, and watch it change over days. Use your breath to make an instant pressure change inside the barometer to see the reading change.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Earth and Space Science: Weather (grade 4)
Materials
  • empty drink bottle, ideally made from stiffer plastic
  • cup of water, or more to fill the bottle up to half way
  • optional: few drops food dye, darker colour better
  • plastic tubing e.g. aquarium tubing, 70cm or longer
  • modelling clay (couple of strips out of a dollar store packet), or for a less messy clay but which doesn't stick quite as well, home made play dough
  • straw cut in half
Procedure

We will make a barometer to measure changes air pressure. Air pressure is caused by the molecules of air piled up on top of each other and pushing down. We do not normally notice these changes, but may have done if we have been in an airplane. The air pressure is quite a bit lower up high, so much so that airplane cabins need to be artificially pressurized so that we can breathe up there.

How to make a bottle barometer, which can show changes in air pressure:
Add the water to the empty drink bottle. Optional: add several drops food dye.
Insert the tubing into the bottle until one end rests on the bottom of the bottle and the other end hangs out of the bottle.
Suck on the tubing end outside of the bottle, until the water almost reaches your mouth.
Take your mouth off the end of the tubing and immediately plug the end with some clay/playdough. If the water level inside the tubing drops out of sight before plugging with clay, retry until the water line is high enough up the tubing to be clearly in view.
Watch the level in the tube for a little while to make sure the modelling clay makes an airtight seal on the end of the tube.
Add a piece of tape to the outside of the tube with a line on it, or on the wall next to where it is taped, to show the initial level of the water.

The level in the tubing will rise up and down as the atmospheric air pressure changes over several days:
Air pushes down on the water surface inside the bottle, which holds the water up in the tube.
If the atmospheric air pressure rises (usually associated with clear weather), the air pushes down more on the water surface inside the bottle, which pushes the water level further along the tube.
If the air pressure drops (usually associated with rainy weather), air pushes down less on the water surface inside the bottle and the water level in the tube will drop.

To immediately see how the water level in the tube changes, use your breath to change the air pressure inside the bottle:
Cut a straw in half and wrap more modelling clay around it, sealing to make sure that there are no air gaps.
Insert the straw into the barometer bottle mouth, and use the clay to seal over the top of the bottle and around the tubing.
Blow into the straw. If their is no air leakage, you will make the air pressure in the bottle rise, which will push the liquid up the tubing.
It takes a lot of puff to move the water line only a little. This gives a sense of the pressure changes that occur in our atmosphere regularly, but we do not notice so much (unless we have arthritis which can cause sensitivity to pressure changes in the joints).

To watch atmospheric air pressure change over time, tape the tube onto a nearby wall. Check regularly, especially when the weather is changing to see the liquid level rise or fall.
Clear weather is associated with higher pressure because local high pressure air will move outwards away from the high pressure region to lower pressure regions around. This air is replaced by air from above.
Rainy weather is associated with lower pressure because local low pressure means that surrounding higher pressure air will move inwards. Then it is forced upwards. The rising air cools and water condenses out forming clouds and often bringing rain.

Grades taught
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Automaton - cardboard and foam machine

Summary
Build a compound machine, that is also an art project, that demonstrates levers, cams, linkages and a chain of forces.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Materials
  • cardboard boxes to cut up
  • blade or cardboard saw
  • scissors
  • masking tape
  • glue gun
  • sturdy skewers
  • wire cutters, or alternative to cut skewers
  • straw that skewer will fit through
  • washers that fit over the skewer, to add weight, or use modelling clay
  • thick foam sheets, 6mm (about one 9X12" sheet for four students)
Procedure

Follow instructions from this activity from the Exploratorium, also attached, and summarized below:
https://www.exploratorium.edu/pie/downloads/Cardboard_Automata.pdf

In brief:
Make a frame from a cardboard box, with triangles to reinforce inside the corners. Note: do not make the frame too large, or there will be too much play and the cams won't mesh. About 20cm wide and 15cm high works well.
Stick a skewer (a "shaft") horizontally through the frame, adding a circle of foam (a "cam") to it, the placement of the hole in the cam depending on which mechanism(s) you want to make. See the attached file from the Exploratorium for ideas. It is best if the cam is at least 5cm diameter.
Add another foam cam on a vertical shaft through the top of the box that will rest on the first circle. Don't make this skewer too long or it will move sideways. A straw glued into the box to guide the skewer helps keep it upright. Washers, or modelling clay, give some weight to the cam so that it always rests on the lower cam.
Depending on where the horizontal shaft goes through its cam, the upright shaft will move round and round, or round and round and up and down.
Optional: add another circle on the horizontal shaft to make the upright shaft also go back and forth.
Decorate the upright shaft, so that the movement(s) is/are highlighted.

Notes

If the box frames are too big, the skewer lengths get too large and there is too much sideways movement.
The Exploratorium new up and down model did not work so well, but check it wasn't because our skewers weren't too long.

Glue gun burn potential means prudent use dependent on the age group and responsibility of kids. If the kids are not mechanically-minded, they will need a lot of individual attention. When an adult has to do all the hot-glueing, some groups get bored waiting around.

Grades taught
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7

Pinball machine

Summary
Use a wooden board, nails and elastic bands to make a pinball machine for marbles. Learn about forces including friction, simple machines and energy.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Materials and Structures (grade 3)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Materials
  • scrap of plywood or wooden board, about 1.5ft by 3/4ft (needs a little length but width does not matter so much)
  • nails, not much longer than the board is thick (or they will be hammered right through)
  • hammer
  • wide elastic bands
  • spring from a retractable pen, or purchased compression spring (e.g. Canadian Tire)
  • long nail that fits through the spring
  • plastic drywall anchor cut short, or tube that the spring can fit inside but the head of the long nail cannot
  • optional: U-nail/staple that can fit over the drywall anchor and secure it to the board (or just angle nails in)
  • optional: glue gun to make a stopper on the nail of the shooter (or wrap an elastic band around the nail)
  • marbles
Procedure

Students hammer nails around the edge of the board, with a curve at the top. Stretch elastic bands over to make a wall around the board.

Make the marble launcher: slide the spring onto the nail then insert the nail through the drywall anchor. Attach the launcher to the bottom corner of the board, inside the wall (right or left side, depending on the handedness of the student), using a staple. Add a blob of hot glue (or an elastic band wrapped tightly) to the end of the nail that is pulled, to stop it from leaving the shooter when it is released.

Make a channel for the marble to travel up after it is released.
Add more nails and elastic bands to the board as desired to make obstacles for the marble.
Add scoring boxes at the bottom of the board.

After students have played with their own pinball machine for a while, sit in a cirlcle to try each others:
Start with each student with their own machine in front of them, then altogether pass to the next student (all in the same direction). Students can keep their own marble to use on all the pinball machines. Keep passing until the students end up with their own machine in front of them.

Notes

Nails I used:7/8" X 17 Ga. 2oz enough for 4 students.

Grades taught
Gr 4
Gr 5

Lever for lifting (heavy) things

Summary
Set up a lever that lifts a (sometimes very heavy) weight.
Science topic (2005 curriculum connection)
Physical Science: Force and Motion (grade 1)
Physical Science: Forces and Simple Machines (grade 5)
Materials

See saw or lever to lift rock

  • 2X6 or 2X8 plank of wood
  • split log for the fulcrum
  • heavy concrete block, or students can lift each other, or rock (see photo)

Lifting a marble up high

  • small chair
  • light, strong 4ft rod e.g. 5/16" diameter wooden stick
  • two small hooks, secured at each end of the rod, facing the same way
  • about 50cm string for lashing rod to chair
  • bucket - handle may be too high so replace with shorter string handle
  • jug for carrying water
  • sink
  • tray to catch spills under the bucket
  • small pot e.g. dollar store plastic shot glasses
  • marble
  • masking tape
  • cloths and mops for spills
Procedure

See saw
Set up the see saw with the 2X6 centred on the split log.

Ask a pair of students to experiment with the see saw. They can either lift a large block (in the photo), or they can try lifting each other. (The objects are heavy, so the students should work slowly and carefully with good communication within the pair). Prompt the students to move the fulcrum and see what difference it makes.
They should find that when the fulcrum is near the load/student, they are easy to push it up in the air, but when it is far from the load, it is very hard (if not impossible).

Students can draw what they discover using standard notation:
The lever arm (plank of wood) is drawn as a straight line, and the fulcrum is a triangle under the line in the correct position. Use arrows to show where force is applied (at one end of the see saw - also called the effort), and where the resulting force is felt (under the concrete weight - also called the load).

Ask the students how the height of the ends of the see saw varies as the fulcrum is moved. They can measure the distances for more accurate recording of the results.
Less force over a greater distance (with the fulcrum near to the weight) is an easier way to lift the weight. However, in this case the weight will not move as high.
The amount of work balances: less force over a greater distance (at one end of the lever) balances more force over a smaller distance (at the other end).

Lifting a rock
Use a long 2X6 or 2X8 as a lever, and a split log as a fulcrum. If students have already experimented with fulcrum placement, ask them to tell you where the fulcrum should be placed to lift a very heavy object [it should be placed very near the rock]. With this arrangement a large rock can be lifted up a few centimetres (higher could be dangerous incase the rock slips sideways) by a child.

Optional: show photos of how people have been using levers for lifting heavy things for thousands of years.
Egyptians used long sticks as levers to move stones e.g. when making pyramids, evidenced by mortises (holes in stones placed for lever use). Try this image link:
https://krisdedecker.typepad.com/.a/6a00e0099229e8883301310fcb6a12970c-…
Indigenous North West Coast large houses are built using levers to raise the massive cedar logs. See page 113 of "Knowing Home: Braiding Indigenous Science with Western Science, Book 1". Try this link: https://greatbearrainforesttrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Knowing…
Archimedes proved by math and geometry how a lever functions, and was quoted as saying "Give me a place to stand and I shall move the world". Try this link for a famous etching: http://www.thwink.org/sustain/glossary/images/LeveragePoint_ArchimedesL…

Lifting a marble, or small load, up high
Can also use to lift a smaller weight high with a heavier weight - see the photo of the upturned chair supporting a lever.
A pot of water is used to lift a marble up high - students were challenged to use a pot of water to lift a marble to table height.
The marble can be successfully lifted when the fulcrum is very near the bucket of water, so that the other end holding the marble can swing up high enough to reach the table top.
Review how a lever works: a lot of force at one end moving a small distance (the bucket full of water) produces a smaller force over a greater distance at the other end (hence the lighter load of the marble can be lifted high enough to reach the table top).
Relate to other levers students might be familiar with e.g. see saw.

Grades taught
Gr K
Gr 1
Gr 2
Gr 3
Gr 4
Gr 5
Gr 6
Gr 7